‘‘American Idol’’ season-two winner Ruben Studdard will perform the ‘‘farewell song’’ used to send off the losing contestants when they depart the show’s top 12.
This year, the song will be a cover of Kenny Loggins’ ‘‘Celebrate Me Home’’ in a new version produced by Terry Lewis and Jimmy Jam. ‘‘It’s very soulful, very heartfelt,’’ Lewis says. ‘‘Ruben is singing his pants off.’’
Those viewers ready to turn the show off and crown front-runner David Archuleta the winner may want to think back to last season. Melinda Doolittle was the one to beat and she ended up in third place. On to tonight's show:
Carly Smithson is first with Heart's "Crazy on You." We weren't crazy about it and it lacked heart.
"Beginning was a little rough for me," Jackson said. Cowell thought it was much better than last week, but still thinks she hasn't found the right song yet. "You haven't chosen that one song that will absolutely get you that moment."
Syesha Mercado was all R&B on Billy Paul's "Me and Mrs. Jones" (changing the gender of Jones, natch). Randy hated the song choice. He wants her to belt 100 percent of the time. Abdul like the interpretation. "I thought it was a bit indulgent," Cowell said.
Brooke White played guitar for half of Carly Simon's "You're So Vain" (stopping for someone reason on the second verse). "It was a great song choice for you," Jackson said.
"Brooke, I absolutely loved it. It was the absolutely perfect song for you. Felt like the artist genuinely picked the song and it didn't sound old-fashion," Cowell said.
Cowell's remarks to "Extra" may have been premature. Chikezie Eze picked "I Believe to My Soul" (written by Ray Charles and made famous by Donny Hathaway) and knocked it out of the park. "You looked better, sounded better," Cowell said. "It was a clever choice in song."
David Cook picked Free's "All Right Now" and his performance was just all right. Cowell felt Cook was "solid, believable," but lacked charisma.
Archuleta sings us out with John Lennon's “Imagine.”
Paula comments were creepy: "I want to squeeze your head off and dangle you from my rearview mirror."
Cowell said the song choice was "risky, but it worked," adding "right now, you're the one to beat."
Vote for the Worst.com's poster boy this season, Danny Noriega, took on The Carpenter's "Superstar." He did a decent job. Cowell thought it was better than last week, but not fantastic. Jackson thought he was over-concentrating.
David Hernandez left no stone unturned with Norman Whitfield and Barrett Strong's "Papa Was a Rollin' Stone." Hernandez added a bit more flourish than I'd like, but the judges liked it. "This was the David Hernandez we fell in love with, " Jackson said. Cowell felt it was the best vocal of the night up until this point.
Jason Yeager abandoned the cabaret theatrics from last week and put in a decent peformance of The Doobie Brothers “Long Train Runnin’.” Cowell felt he looked like he was a drunk at a party.
Jason Castro came across as shy and genuine in the pre-performance interview. I liked his acoustic-tinged version of The Bee Gees' "I Just Want to Be Your Everything" better than the judges did. "[The vocals were] just ok without the guitar," Jackson said. Cowell found it too schmaltzy.
Luke Menard mystifies me. Second week of the competition and he picked "Killer Queen" by Queen as his choice. It's a difficult song to sing and not one that will exactly endear him to the typical "American Idol" voter. Cowell thinks it was a mistake. Abdul and Jackson both liked it.
Faux rocker Robbie Carrico lost the bandanna this week and makes a good song choice in Foreigner's "Hot Blooded." Randy didn't think it had enough "umph" and Abdul thought he played it too safe.
Syesha Mercado sang the hell out of John D. Loudermilk's "Tobacco Road."
"You're one of the most talented girls in this competition," Cowell said. "I thought it was terrific."
The coveted last spot went to Carly Smithson. Smithson came clean on this being her second chance (she was previously signed and dropped from a record label).
She selected Johnny Mandel and Paul Francis Webster's "The Shadow of Your Smile. "
“Best vocal of the best 24 right here,” Jackson said.
“I didn’t get it. I didn’t think it was fantastic," Cowell said.
16 year-old Alaina Whitaker warbled her way though Spiral Starecase's "More Today Than Yesterday" and did a much better job with it than Chikezie Eze did last night.
"You are sailing through to the next round after that [performance]," Cowell said.
Kristy Lee Cook is the first up. She sold a horse to try out for "American Idol." She seems to need rescuing from her rather generic version of Aretha Franklin's "Rescue Me."
Randy Jackson said it was not her best performance. Paula Abdul said despite the bronchitis and flu Cook shouldn't "let it get in the way of your shine or what you emote" (whatever that means). Simon Cowell put it bluntly: "Bronchitis, flu, whatever. It was the wrong choice of song for you."
Plus size-model Joanne Borgella was next with Burt Bacharach's "I Say a Little Prayer For You." She seemed
Last night's episode of "American Idol" seemed to feature a lot of filler in the form of banter between the judges. Hopefully, tonight will be different as the ladies take the stage.
Ryan Seacrest just explained that flu season has hit the "Idol" contestants. I think this might have been an attempt to explain Carly Smithson's absence last night (she was missing from the crowd of 11 female singers watching their male counterparts perform).
"American Idol" finally got down to business as the 12 male contestants performed Tuesday night.
The theme is music from the 1960s. First up was David Hernandez. . He gave a gospel-fueled version of Wilson Pickett’s “In the Midnight Hour.” Cowell said it was better than he expected, but Hernandez needed to loosen up.
Chikezie Eze sang Spiral Staircase’s “More Today Than Yesterday” in full Barry White mode. Cowell hated the suit, the wink and the old-fashioned performance.
While David Cook rocked out to "So Happy Together," the same could not be said for Jason Yeager.
David Archuleta sings "Heaven" by Bryan Adams. Three yes votes. I'm guessing his fans are going to call themselves "Arch Angels," because this kids is top 10 material.
Simon apologized for walking out on Kyle. Kyle redeems himself and is passed onto the final round of cuts.
Syesha, who had been suffering with a throat ailment, comes back like a gale wind with "Chain of Fools."
Michael Johns sings "Bohemian Rhapsody. Three yes votes
Chicago's Pia Easley is in the first group of 10. We don't hear her sing. She's sent home. So much for being one of Entertainment Weekly's picks to make it through.
With 160 contestants competing at the start of "American Idol" Hollywood week tonight, we can only hope that Paula, Randy and Simon will show a little love for the lone two Chicago contestants to make the trek: Pia Easley and Angela Martin.
No one ever accused Simon Cowell of being compassionate — until this year.
Three weeks into the new season, the resident ‘‘American Idol’’ grinch has been sugarcoating critiques of mediocre and helplessly tone-deaf wannabes.
‘‘He’s nice for three weeks, and then suddenly he’ll flip and he’ll turn out being [a] bloody horror again,’’ said ‘‘Idol’’ executive producer Ken Warwick. ‘‘Wait until we get into this next batch, you know, the top 12.’’
Recent Comments