"Never Can Say Goodbye" and it's a total R&B snooze fest. He's got a great voice, you just wish he did something different with the arrangement.
"This wouldn't have been the song I would have chosen for you," Jackson said.
"DioGuardi calls him out for not being emotionally connecte.
"I don't feel you were yourself," Abdul said.
"It was so old fashioned, actually I couldn't wait for it to end," Cowell said.