Brooke White picked up the pace with "Here Comes the Sun." It's pretty, she just can't shake that whole "Carly Simon" thing.
"That performance was awkward for me," Jackson said. "You were never really connected to that song."
"You can't help but smile when you watch you perform," Paula Abdul said.
"It was wet, forgettable," Cowell said, sounding more like Abdul in his critique. Just exactly how is a performance wet?