On immigration: McCain put political career in peril; Obama overstates leadership role.

| | Comments (5)

UPDATE: The Obama team sent over a PDF of a letter from Sen. Mel Martinez (R-Fl.) thanking Obama for his work on immigration legislation that eventually stalled. This is to rebut the assertion from McCain backer Martinez on Friday and in the column, from Sen. Lindsey Graham that Obama was not around to help when it mattered. http://www.suntimes.com/images/cds/MP3/Martinezletter.pdf END UPDATE

WASHINGTON -- No matter if you are—or are not — voting for presumptive GOP nominee Sen. John McCain (R-Az.), he deserves credit for trying to forge a bipartisan deal on immigration in 2005 and 2006 at great personal political risk, a situation unfamiliar to rival Sen. Barack Obama (D-Ill.)

McCain put his comeback presidential bid in peril because of his leadership role with Sen. Ted Kennedy (D-Mass.) to find a path for millions of illegal immigrants to stay in the U.S.

The Kennedy-McCain legislation stalled in 2006, because the hardline pro- and anti-immigration forces preferred the status quo to a compromise. Another try in 2007 — in a bill backed by McCain and Obama — also failed.

McCain and Obama, wooing Hispanic voters, each has madeclear in recent appearances before the National Association of Latino Elected Officials and the League of United Latino American Citizens a few days ago that he would make immigration reform — and legalizing the status of millions of illegal immigrants — a priority if elected president. I expect each to send the same message at the upcoming National Council of La Raza conference in San Diego, where Obama speaks Sunday and McCain on Monday.

In the meantime, Obama on the campaign trail inflates his leadership role — casting himself as someone who could figure out how to get something done. Obama “did not absolutely stand out in any way,’’ said Margaret Sands Orchowski, the author of “Immigration and the American Dream: Battling the Political Hype and Hysteria,” and a close follower of the legislation.

Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.), a McCain ally and a key player on immigration, said Obama was around for only a “handful” of meetings and helped destroy a 2007 compromise when he voted for making guest worker visa programs temporary. A permanent guest worker program was to be a trade for a legalization program to cover many illegal immigrants.

“When it came time to putting that bill together, he was more of a problem than he was a help. And when it came time to try to get the bill passed, he, in my opinion, broke the agreement we had. He was in the photo op, but he could not execute the hard part of the deal,” Graham said,” Graham said.

An Obama Senate staffer who did not want his name used disputed whether the sunset provision in the guest worker program killed the bill and said that either Obama or his top immigration staffer were in strategy sessions and that Kennedy, in his speech endorsing Obama vouched for Obama’s work on immigration.

In praising Obama for his work on immigration, Kennedy said of Obama, "There is the tireless skill of a senator who was there in the early mornings to help us hammer out a needed compromise on immigration reform, who always saw a way to protect national security and the dignity of people who did not have a vote. For them, he was a voice for justice, a voice for justice. For them, he was a voice for justice."

On Thursday in Fairfax, Va., Obama was asked about his qualifications to understand Latino needs. After noting his work as a community organizer and state senator — he spoke of McCain. “John McCain bucked much of his party and worked with Ted Kennedy, worked with me and others to help shape comprehensive immigration reform legislation in the Senate. And I thought that was courageous of him.” Obama, in a sly verbal stroke, made himself an equal on immigration leadership to Kennedy and demoted McCain to a helper.

McCain—after the two failed attempts to pass a comprehensive bill — now wants to satisfy conservatives by first passing a border security and enforcement measure.

Obama said that approach means McCain “can’t give you confidence that he is going to be serious about that issue. I will be.”

McCain is not saying enforcement only. He is saying enforcement first.



I am an American citizen who happens to be Hispanic, and I disagree also with Obama's remark this week.

"Voters Reject Obama's Call for Bilingualism"

"Wednesday, July 09, 2008 Email to a FriendAdvertisement

Barack Obama said yesterday that “instead of worrying about whether immigrants can learn English,” Americans “need to make sure your child can speak Spanish.” A national telephone survey conducted last month by Rasmussen Reports found that U.S. voters overwhelmingly disagree with the presumptive Democratic presidential nominee. (see video)"
Rasmussen Reports

Once again................

The typical Chicago-made, Chicagoan style politician.........

Obama is trying to get the Hispanic vote.....(from those who are American citizens).

The essential question:

Is Obama's word to be trusted????????????

Excellent article Lynn. Thank you for writing about policy differences instead of about which candidate is in the lead.

This is an unfair title Lynn. What does it say that McCain has flip-flopped on his own legislation at election time? You can not allow McCain to have it both ways -- support the legislation when you are not accountable to voters, and then flip-flop when you are.

To make it worse, now McCain is trying to aggressively take credit when he has thrown Hispanics under the bus.

Be Critical of Obama, but do not allow McCain to have a free-pass at a huge policy reversal.

Lynn further those at least one of those amendments were actually supported by La Raza...

Please revise your article with impartial OBJECTIVE information as opposed to talking points from one side.

Leave a comment

Lynn Sweet

Lynn Sweet is a columnist and the Washington Bureau Chief for the Chicago Sun-Times.

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Lynn Sweet published on July 12, 2008 9:23 AM.

Obama at Park West fund-raising concert says "I love Wilco." was the previous entry in this blog.

Former White House Secretary Tony Snow dies after battle with cancer. So long, Tony. is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.