Closed 6/11/07
30th Anniversary Poll: What's your favorite Star War(s)?
Categories:
epigraphs
"I don't think you go to a play to forget, or to a movie to be distracted. I think life generally is a distraction and that going to a movie is a way to get back, not go away." -- Tom Noonan
"Cinema is a matter of what's in the frame and what's out." -- Martin Scorsese
“An idea does not exist apart from the words that express it. Style is not an envelope enclosing a message; the envelope is the message.” -- Dwight Macdonald
"There's nothing I like less than bad arguments for a view that I hold dear." -- Daniel Dennett
recent comments
- Jim N (Not E) commented on Why Brad Pitt should win the Oscar: All I have to do is be re
- Chalkie commented on Why Brad Pitt should win the Oscar: If Oscar hadn't lost cred
- Dave commented on Why Brad Pitt should win the Oscar: I'm always impressed with
- João Solimeo commented on Watching (and listening to) Fincher's Girl : Very interesting essay, J
- Andrew Davies commented on Why Brad Pitt should win the Oscar: I think if it wasn't for
- keith carrizosa commented on The Artist: Everybody loves/hates a frontrunner!: About why he didn't w
- Alex Murillo commented on Why Brad Pitt should win the Oscar: I thought when I saw it t
- cmilne commented on Why Brad Pitt should win the Oscar: Brad Pitt is a very rare
- Jim Emerson commented on The Artist: Everybody loves/hates a frontrunner!: It promotes the kind of r
- Brian Rose commented on The Artist: Everybody loves/hates a frontrunner!: What is comes down to for
- OMG commented on The Artist: Everybody loves/hates a frontrunner!: "Actively evil," Jim, ser
- Dennis Cozzalio commented on Come ona Tree House (of Life): Jeremy, come back! Come b
- Phil C commented on Our Father: The Tree of Life: Do you happen to know the
- Doug Braverman commented on The Artist: Everybody loves/hates a frontrunner!: Since the film ends with
- The Siren commented on The Artist: Everybody loves/hates a frontrunner!: Jim, there seems to be so
- jbryant commented on The Artist: Everybody loves/hates a frontrunner!: This is another good reas
- Egbert Souse commented on The Artist: Everybody loves/hates a frontrunner!: I'm biased in enjoying Th
- The Siren commented on The Artist: Everybody loves/hates a frontrunner!: P.S. As for the accent, R
- joel commented on The Artist: Everybody loves/hates a frontrunner!: Thanks for posting my fol
- K. commented on The Artist: Everybody loves/hates a frontrunner!: When I saw the film, seei
selected articles
- Plumbing in the Cinema
- Buster Keaton
- TwinPeaks
- Barry Lyndon
- 'Birth' of a Buñuelian Notion
- Donnie Darko
- Fight Club
- War of the Worlds
- Mind Games & Head Trips
- Politics & Movies
- Miller's Crossing
- Sansho the Bailiff
- The Coen Bros.
- Million Dollar Baby
- The Big Lie
- When Bad Movies Happen to Good People
- Munich
- Jeeem's Pantheon
- 120Favorite Movies
categories
- A Serious Man (5)
- Acting (31)
- Books (15)
- Censorship (22)
- Cinematography (9)
- Comedy (171)
- Contrarian Week (12)
- Contrarianism Blog-a-Thon (5)
- Critical Thinking (100)
- Critics & criticism (441)
- DVD (35)
- Directors & direction (147)
- Dogs (12)
- Editing (13)
- Exhibition (8)
- Extras (1)
- Festivals & events (60)
- Film noir (3)
- Funny Games experiment (6)
- Horror (57)
- In the Cut (3)
- Inglourious Basterds (10)
- Journalism (83)
- Language (31)
- Mad Men (6)
- Movies (195)
- Music (46)
- No Country for Old Men (19)
- Obits & tributes (44)
- Opening Shots Index (1)
- Opening Shots Project (87)
- Opening Shots Project, Part 2 (5)
- Oscars (36)
- Politics (121)
- Religion (45)
- Sex (26)
- Sound (3)
- TIFF 2006 (24)
- TIFF 2007 (21)
- TIFF 2008 (12)
- TV (85)
- Technology (78)
- The Biz (94)
- The Dark Knight (19)
- The Descent (4)
- The Social Network (8)
- Trapped in the Closet (6)
- VIFF 2009 (7)
- VIFF 2011 (4)
- Video essay (21)
- Writing (8)
search
tweet / facebook
recent entries
- Emotional fascism -- er, criticism
- Climb on up into the Movie Tree House!
- Trash Humpers not banned, hump trash
- National Society: The last best critics awards for 2010
- Scanners' Exploding Head Awards 2010
- Locating the difference between a good movie and a not-so-good one
- Big buttocks & curry killers: Worst of Bollywood 2010
- Making contact: Spielberg's Close Encounters and E.T.
- And the poll-winners are...
- Why Soderbergh is retiring soon
- The Ultimate Internet Commenting Guidelines
- Panahi gets six years; banned from film for 20
- Moments Out of Time 2010
- The year's beasts: MSN critics' top 10 for 2010
- LA & NY crix love The Social Network and Carlos
- Darren Aronofsky agrees with me
- My capsule review of Client 9
- The naked truth about Airport Security Theater
- Nothing is real(ism), and nothing to get hung about
- The Return of the Autobiographical Dictionary of Film
google connect
February 2012
critics
- Roger Ebert
- David Ansen
- Michael Atkinson
- David Bordwell
- Ty Burr
- Richard Corliss
- Manohla Dargis
- David Denby
- DVD Savant
- David Edelstein
- David Ehrenstein
- Scott Foundas
- Chris Fujiwara
- John Hartl
- J. Hoberman
- Richard T. Jameson
- Dave Kehr
- Glenn Kenny
- Leonard Maltin
- Kim Morgan
- Wesley Morris
- Kathleen Murphy
- Andrew O'Hehir
- John Patterson
- Gerald Peary
- John Powers
- Peter Rainer
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
- A.O. Scott
- Henry Sheehan
- Kristin Thompson
- Michael Wilmington
- Matt Zoller Seitz
blogs, journals & zines
- AltScreen
- Antagony & Ecstasy
- Art of the Title
- Aspect Ratio
- Balboa Theater Newsletter (Gary Meyer)
- Big Media Vandalism
- Breaking the line
- Cahiers du Cinema (English)
- Cerebral Mastication
- Cinebeats
- Cinema Scope
- Cinemasparagus
- Cinema Styles
- Cinema Treasures
- The Cinematic Art
- CinePassion
- coffee, coffee ... and more coffee
- The Cooler
- Discours du Cinéma
- Edward Copeland
- Elusive Lucidity
- The Evening Class
- Filmbrain
- a_film_by
- Film International
- TheFilmsaurus Film Studies For Free
- Filmsound Daily
- The Fine Cut
- Flickhead
- The Greatest Films
- Girish
- Greenbriar Picture Shows
- GreenCine Daily
- Hell on Frisco Bay
- The House Next Door
- If Charlie Parker Was a Gunslinger...
- IFC Blog
- images: a journal of film and popular culture
- j.j. murphy on independent cinema
- Kubrick Multimedia Archive
- Living in Cinema
- Aspect Ratio
- LOLA
- Masters of Cinema
- My Five Year Plan
- The Niles Files
- Not Coming to a Theater Near You
- Offscreen
- Parallax View
- Phil-zine!
- Press Play
- Reverse Shot
- Rouge
- Screenville
- Senses of Cinema
- Sergio Leone and the Infield Fly Rule
- The Seventh Art
- The Sheila Variations
- Shoot First, Mumble Later
- Sight & Sound
- Silly Hats Only
- sixmartinis and the seventh art
- Spectacular Attractions
- Strictly Film School
- Offscreen
- Tales of OdieNary Madness
- They Shoot Pictures, Don't They?
- Vinyl Is Heavy
- Undercurrent (FIPRESCI)
- when canses were classeled...
6 Comments
Why has Close Encouters of the Third Kind been included in this poll? It is funny because somehow Close Encounters has received more votes than Return of the Jedi.
highritz: Had to put "Star Wars" into some kind of perspective. In 1977 it seemed the world was divided into four camps: those who adored/preferred "Star Wars"; those who adored/preferred "CE3K"; those who liked both; and those who liked neither. That's why I threw in "CE3K" as another option...
I picked Jedi, for that purest of reasons: It was the first one I saw as a kid, so for me Star Wars is Jabba's Palace, the Forest Moon of Endor, and that final, amazing lightsaber battle between Luke and Darth.
Empire Strikes Back. For me, it's the most enjoyable.
Never cared for the prequels. The only one I kinda liked was Ep. 3.
Ha ha! Phantom Menace and Clones seem to share a mouseover pixel. I couldn't even see Phantom menace. I voted CE3K, but my real answer is Empire.
I'm not suprised that The Empire Strikes Back has gotten the most votes and I'm glad that its is getting the cult following that I think it has earned because critics panned when first released (but then again the star wars movies have never done well in terms of critical reception).also,I can understand why emerson had it in his 102 must see before... movies list because out of all the star wars movies this has arguably the best artistic merits.I didn't think phantom menace was a bad movie as many thought it was because it had enough colorful characters(I thought darth maul was cool) and set-pieces(like the underwater gungan city) to sustain an entire film, making the film fun to watch.Though the jar jar binks character did give the film a terrible level of kitch just like the ewoks did in jedi.
Leave a comment