Two very different fanbases squealed sighs of relief this month upon seeing their musical heroes return to action. This week, David Bowie, 66, released his first album in a decade, "The Next Day." Next week, Justin..." />
Tuning in with Thomas Conner

Review: Justin Timberlake, 'The 20/20 Experience'

| 7 Comments | No TrackBacks

(RCA) 3<br />
stars
JT2020.jpgTwo very different fanbases squealed sighs of relief this month upon seeing their musical heroes return to action. This week, David Bowie, 66, released his first album in a decade, "The Next Day." Next week, Justin Timberlake, 32, delivers his first album in six years, "The 20/20 Experience" (currently streaming on iTunes ahead of its release next week). I wouldn't dream of comparing the sound and vision of these gents, but (aside from the temporal puzzles in their titles) the two albums share a particular foundational perspective -- that of an iconic artist seeking to make solid new music without hitching rides on any shiny, new bandwagons.

Timberlake's outing is promising, though the full delivery of that promise requires patience and repeated listening. This album's a grower, not a shower.

It is most definitely not a sequel to 2006's "FutureSex/Lovesounds." Like Bowie, Timberlake has reteamed with a trusted producer who helmed his breakthrough moment -- savvy sonic architect Timbaland -- and together they distill the good stuff from their past triumphs. They don't, however, amplify those qualities. Instead, they crystallize them, ever so slowly.

"The 20/20 Experience" is a long album (too long, yes), while laid back and supple. Most songs stretch on and on, and then morph into completely different songs. "Pusher Love Girl" opens the affair on a relaxed, strolling beat, with Timberlake flinging his falsetto far and high (it stops just short of being campy, but barely). After five minutes, the song drifts into an extended jam of vocal samples and a skittering rhythm, wrapping up at the eight-minute mark and leaving the listener bothered and bewildered.

Throughout the album, songs U-turn like this and drive on for miles more. "Don't Hold the Wall" -- the album's coolest track, rich with Timbaland production including moaning tribal wails and rainsticks -- breaks midway through into a foggy tempo dazed by echoing voices and effects. "Mirrors" muddles along as a dreadful Maroon 5 knock-off before devolving into a second half of Oompa Loompa chants and aimless crooning. "Strawberry Bubblegum" uses its switcheroo to its advantage, building the sexual tension during the first half's subtle, blippy beats, then cranking up the Casio bossa nova and upping the allure, as if he's been eyeing the girl smacking the gum and now he's got that taste in his mouth as he dims the lights.

Musically, though, nothing here comes on strong, which is the album's blessing and curse. The sounds are light and densely layered -- there's plenty to discover, and even "Suit & Tie," the breezy comeback single, appreciates over time and may have long legs this summer. But often one gets the sense that Timberlake and Timbaland were so chill in the studio they let things roll on too long. "Spaceship Coupe" is the lowest point, actually collapsing for lack of any structure to hold it up (or, possibly, from embarrassment over the absurd lyrics, a common JT issue). The Memphis samples, horns and vocal styling on "That Girl" apes Al Green a little too winky-winky and never reaches full steam. Sometimes Timberlake gets so deep into his own flow he forgets to swim.

Given the hyped, tuxedoed performance at the Grammys with the big band, I had expected "The 20/20 Experience" to be packed with retro razzle-dazzle. Not so much. MTV has labeled the album "part Frank Sinatra, part Frank Ocean," addressing its mixture of sly classicism and smooth presence. "C'mon, shake it, you know, like you got something to prove," Timberlake sings in "Let the Groove Get In," an assault of African rhythm and chant. But it's clear he feels he's got nothing to prove, like Jay-Z -- who apparently is destined to be JT's shadow throughout 2013, joining him on the tour that reaches Chicago's Soldier Field on July 22. This is a 2<br />
and a half stars album, with the extra half thrown in for how much better it's likely to sound by the time they get here.


No TrackBacks

TrackBack URL: http://blogs.suntimes.com/cgi-bin/mt-tb.cgi/55333

7 Comments

OMG...a reviewer is not praising JT just cause he put out music. I have to agree with many of your points. I was listening to the album and actually get'n annoyed at how long the songs were. What bothers me is that no song on the album is epic enough to deserve so much time. I get what JT was trying to do, but he failed IMO. The album is kinda boring cause Timbalands beats no longer make up for JT's lyrics.

Looking forward to listening to this album!

Can't wait for JT's new album to come out, been a fan for a long time and I really like what I've heard so far. Check out "Mirrors": http://smarturl.it/JTMirrorVEVO

If you don't like the album then it's probably because you don't like JT or Timbaland. The album is rather enjoyable and I'd have to say that Timbaland's beats are some of his best and I like how they are used within the tracks. JT's voice is, well....JT.

This is Jorge Bergoglio's second favorite record just after Wesley Willis' "Metal Clink Punishment Jail."

Definitely agree that it's a grower - not a shower. My first initial listen I was like... well there's only 3 songs on this album: Suit & Tie, Mirrors, Pusher Love. Every other track is just beats. But after listening to it (since iTunes has it streaming all week) about 20+ times, it's definitely grown on me. I like Timbaland's beats and I think JT has definitely grown since his boy band days. I personally like that the songs morph into something else for a couple of minutes. I hope we don't have to wait another 6 years for his next album.

I have to disagree with the reviewer and i will sayI love this album.Music is an art that everyone can appreciate and just like any other form of art...some art speaks to people while others do not..if you dont feel it in your soul then its not for you. i felt every beat and lyric..it took me away to another place and thats what i love about it. ive been an avid JT fan for 15 years. Personally i love the album because it is rich with sounds,beats.each song definitely has its own vibe..each sets its own mood. I will admit that on first listen i did feel the songs were too long because i do like how the songs beat totally changes at then end but then it kept going and i was like ok..i wanna hear the rest of the album already..but now that ive been listening non stop i can say it no longer bothers me...i love everysong on the album! I hear a part 2 may be coming out in november...bring it on!!!!

Leave a comment

Thomas Conner

Thomas Conner covers pop music for the Chicago Sun-Times. Contact him via e-mail.

Pages

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Thomas Conner published on March 12, 2013 7:41 PM.

St. Pat's: Tossers, Drovers back for anniversary pints was the previous entry in this blog.

SXSW 2013 opens with names big and small is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.