Chicago Sun-Times
Tuning in with Thomas Conner

Too late, too soon: One Direction @ Allstate Arena

| 2 Comments | No TrackBacks


(Photos by Chandler West/Sun-Times)

She was one girl among hundreds in line at a merchandise booth Saturday night inside Allstate Arena, waiting to buy One Direction mugs ($20), One Direction soda cups ($5), One Direction laminates ($10), One Direction glow sticks ($15), One Direction stickers ($5) and a dozen different One Direction T-shirts ($35-$40). Merchandise sales, in fact, opened on Friday to accommodate the throngs.

Hope, 12, was squeezing her mom's wallet and practically hyperventilating.

"I just can't believe it!" she gasped. "They're in this building right now! They're breathing the same air I am!"

If you haven't clued in to One Direction yet, be patient. A massive marketing machine is about to overheat in an effort to overexpose them.

Already a phenomenon in their native Britain, these five lads -- Zayn Malik, Liam Payne, Harry Styles, Louis Tomlinson and Niall Horan -- competed on but didn't win Simon Cowell's TV talent show "X Factor" in 2010. Cowell, ever the pop culture mercenary, signed them anyway. The first One Direction album, "Up All Night," all pleasant pop and puppy love, debuted at No. 1 earlier this year and spawned three top 10 singles ("Gotta Be You," "One Thing" and "What Makes You Beautiful").

One Direction is now in the middle of their first headlining tour; a DVD of it, however, is already for sale ("Up All Night: The Live Tour"). Plus, in a surprising gamble for such an embryonic act, tickets for the group's next tour are already available -- with 101 shows booked thus far next summer, including a return to the Chicago area July 13-14, 2013.

"U2 went on sale over a year in advance, and One Direction shows are selling very strong for 2013," Mark Campana, the Chicago-based co-president of North American concerts for concert promoter Live Nation, said Saturday night after the show. "They are all tracking towards easy sellouts."

Why the hard sell? Because time's a-wasting. The boys of One Direction are already men. Unlike New Kids on the Block, Backstreet Boys, Hanson, the Jonas Brothers and even Justin Bieber before them, 1D arrived to the boy-band party late -- on the threshold of their 18th birthdays. Heck, Tomlinson is 20.

So the direction of 1D is clear -- to the bank, and hurry.

The cynicism of One Direction's prefabrication is immediately evident in their lack of preparation. Each member can sing quite well, solo and in harmony -- and that's it. There's no dancing, no blocking, no obvious effort to otherwise entertain or engage. Of course, there's no need. Before the latest generation of breathless young girls, the slightest dimpled smirk, winsome smile or struck pose elicits deafening squeals.

But if you've ever cracked jokes about typical boy-band choreography, you'd learn to appreciate it after watching the 1D guys aimlessly wander the stage for 90 minutes. They horse around a little. They play air guitar. As a concertgoer, the experience is akin to proctoring a study hall. After a while, you'd kill for some synchronized twirls and anything resembling razzle-dazzle. Even one of the openers, fellow "X Factor" castaway Olly Murs, occasionally rose above his milquetoast Bruno Mars shtick for a little coordinated moonwalking.

What are highly choreographed are the costume changes. The style is basic Hilfiger family reunion and was divided among three seasonal color palettes announced via the video screens: "summer hols," "autumn term" and "winter season."

No spring -- not enough songs yet for a whole year. With just the one album thus far, 1D pads the set with covers (Kings of Leon's "Use Somebody," an acoustic medley that includes huge hits by Black Eyed Peas and Natalie Imbruglia, both of them stolen by Horan on acoustic guitar and occasional scissor kicks) plus 10 minutes of answering inane questions tweeted by fans ("Which 'Friends' character would you be?" etc.).


But now the $39.50-$89.50 question: Will fans still think this is worth squealing for next summer (when they remember they bought a ticket more than a year ago)? Are Hope's squeals eternal?

More importantly, will the 1D boys themselves even make it to summer '13 without collapsing? With more than 50 shows through this August, a second album to finish recording in Sweden and hundreds more shows next year, it's no surprise Rolling Stone editor Andy Greene recently observed "they're working them like dogs."

Then again, he also added that One Direction is "printing money right now." Come next summer -- even if the arenas and amphitheaters are half empty because fickle fans have moved on or because One Direction ends up doing a U-turn in the States -- hey, they've already got your dough.

One Direction set list Saturday night:
"Na Na Na"
"Stand Up"
"I Wish"
Medley: "I Gotta Feeling"/"Stereo Hearts"/"Valerie"/"Torn"
"Gotta Be You"
"More Than This"
"Up All Night"
"Tell Me a Lie"
"Everything About You"
"Use Somebody"
"One Thing"
"Save You Tonight"
"What Makes You Beautiful"
"I Want"

No TrackBacks

TrackBack URL:


I Love One Direction!!!!!!!

I love 1D ur the best!! I love 1D so much I absolutly love your song rock me! And RIP nails braces lol bye
Syd your biggest fan

Leave a comment

Thomas Conner

Thomas Conner covers pop music for the Chicago Sun-Times. Contact him via e-mail.


About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Thomas Conner published on June 3, 2012 1:47 AM.

Music reviews: Neil Young & Crazy Horse, Sun Kil Moon, more was the previous entry in this blog.

City Winery slates music for 'sophisticated' new venue is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.