John Legend & the Roots, "Wake Up!" (Good-Columbia) stars" border="0" align=middle> Even bad sex with another human being is better than good sex with a machine. For its third full-length outing,..." />
Chicago Sun-Times
Tuning in with Thomas Conner

Maroon 5, 'Hands All Over'; John Legend & the Roots, 'Wake Up!'

| 2 Comments | No TrackBacks

Maroon 5, "Hands All Over" (A&M-Octone) 1<br />
star
John Legend & the Roots, "Wake Up!" (Good-Columbia) 2<br />
stars

maroon5hands.jpgEven bad sex with another human being is better than good sex with a machine. For its third full-length outing, Maroon 5 turned over its sometimes sexy, usually soulful pop sound to hard rock producer Robert John "Mutt" Lange (Def Leppard, AC/DC). The result is the glossy, carefully tooled set "Hands All Over," the title of which is about the only indication that this music was produced by human hands.

Hiring Lange was an interesting left turn. Would the band crank up the backbeat and rock the power chords? No, Lange's chief result seems to be merely coating Maroon 5's potent albeit lite-R&B with musical polyurethane. Singer Adam Levine once convinced us how hard it was to breathe around a certain woman. Here, he sounds short of breath in a claustrophobic, computer-compressed production that squeezes dry much of the passion that made this band rise above its middle-of-the-road, power-pop roots.

His "Misery" in the opening track sounds real; his occasional rhythmic "unh!" is flaccid. The title track and "Never Gonna Leave This Bed" speak of sexiness, but they don't swing at all with a natural rhythm, nothing like a human body. "Give a Little More" almost cuts loose, but across the bulk of the album you can almost hear the click track: the players are slaves to oppressively programmed machine time. It's rigid, not randy.

rootslegend.jpgFor a distinctly human presence in R&B, you can "Wake Up!" to the new collaboration between singer John Legend and the Roots. A disc of 11 soul classics and album cuts from the '60s and '70s, plus one original song, "Wake Up!" isn't the jolt its title implies (indeed, Harold Melvin & the Blue Notes' "Wake Up Everybody," even with Common's mid-song rap, is more of a lullaby), but it rolls with a few targeted grooves and just enough conviction to inspire. The Roots, despite a couple of years with day jobs as Jimmy Fallon's TV show band, fuel and update the songs with real swing, even if they don't exactly transcend the material. Legend might be the weak link; he's not the grittiest singer to be tackling this particular set list -- he's often a boy in a man's studio here, especially when he gamely but lamely yeah's through the 12-minute arc of Bill Withers' wartime lament "I Can't Write Left-Handed" -- but his ease mostly makes a dynamic foil for the Roots' muscle and the frequent guest vocals. The mix is particularly potent on Ernie Hines' "Our Generation," featuring a hot rap from CL Smooth, and the jaunty spirit of Nina Simone's "I Wish I Knew How It Would Feel to Be Free." Alas, Legend's new "Shine" ends the set with a whimper.

No TrackBacks

TrackBack URL: http://blogs.suntimes.com/cgi-bin/mt-tb.cgi/35686

2 Comments

Ha! That Maroon 5 review is funny! That band has simply become something annoying!

-Paul

I agree with the review. I was also disappointed with "Wake Up!" The one song I did enjoy was "I Can't Write Left-Handed" but other than that it seemed more gospel than hip-hop and John Legend did entirely too much screaming.

Leave a comment

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Thomas Conner published on September 23, 2010 3:00 PM.

The Kinks won't 'Do It Again,' but documentary filmmaker tried was the previous entry in this blog.

M.I.A. + Kanye = Two artists who feel very misunderstood is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.