Chicago Sun-Times
Tuning in with Thomas Conner

Sonic Youth, "The Eternal" (Matador) [3.5 STARS]

| 4 Comments | No TrackBacks


While critical consensus held that the long-running New York art-punks' last album "Rather Ripped" (2006) was its most tuneful in ages--"Sonic Youth are the best band in the universe," rock-crit dean Robert Christgau gushed--I just didn't hear the consistency, concision and vitality that marks the group's best efforts: "Bad Moon Rising" (1985), "Sister" and "Evol" (1986), "Daydream Nation" (1988) and "Goo" (1990). And, after the long string of relative duds that it's been giving us since 1994, I though it unlikely that Sonic Youth would ever regain those peaks again.

Well whaddya know? Seemingly reinvigorated by their departure from the major-label ranks (yes, the band that brought Nirvana to Geffen has, a decade and a half after the end of the alternative-rock movement, finally moved to Matador) and another "fifth Youth" lineup change (Jim O'Rourke left two albums ago, and he's been replaced by Mark Ibold of Pavement on bass as Kim Gordon moves to guitar), the band has given us a 16th studio album that stands as its freshest, most spirited and just plain best in 17 years. "This album is a celebration of newfound freedom," Thurston Moore has said. "Releasing this album with our friends at Matador feels like liberation, which inspired us during the recording process."

Never mind that Sonic Youth always has posited itself as the least-compromising band in rock; "a celebration of newfound freedom" is exactly what these 12 tracks sound like, from the opening joy-in-noise manifesto of "Sacred Trickster" ("Press up against the amp/Turn up the treble, don't forget!/Getting dizzy, sitting around/Sacred trickster in a lo-tech sound!") through the closing epic of the tellingly entitled "Massage the History."

As those two bookends indicate, Sonic Youth isn't breaking new ground here: We've heard variations on every sound it's exploring, from the postmodern Hawkwind space-rock to the fractured "Goo"/"Dirty" pop tunes to the aforementioned guitar trance-out epic. And the lyrics are predictably dismissible, whether they're imitating/paying tribute to second-tier Beat poetry (having hailed Allen Ginsberg in the past, this time they champion Gregory Corso) or just making us scratch our heads in bewildered stupefaction ("Penetration destroys the body/Violation of a cosmic body/Do you understand the problem?/Anti-war is anti-orgasm").

But 30 years into a career that has, at alternating moments, been both dramatically under- and ridiculously overrated, Sonic Youth has delivered a masterful disc to remind us why we cared.

No TrackBacks

TrackBack URL:


O'Rourke wasn't on the last album (Rather Ripped), he left after Sonic Nurse.

I was hoping a review that would actually analyze the music and lyrics specifically, not some vague discription of random songs. "Joy-in-noise" could be any Sonic Youth song. You got many of the albums mixed up: Bad Moon Rising is definitly a sophomore album and Jim O'Rourke left after Sonic Nurse.

Stick to pop music: musics as mindless as the review.

You don't have to like sonic youth, but you should at least describe better the reasons why, or just let another person write this article, didn't you?! ok, sonic youth had some weak moments last years, but the best album in 17 years? And 3,5? Kiddo, you can listen to music or are you dumb?? Have you listened to Washing Machine?? As a journalist or anything you call yourself, you are a good butcher! TY for wasting my time...

This review sucks. It clearly demonstrates how poorly the reviewer knows SY or even cares about their music. To state that SY reached their zenith with Goo is ridiculous. As others note, have you listened to Washing Machine? What about some of the profound tracks on Thousand Leaves or Murray Street? I personally think Rather Ripped is overrated compared to Murray Street and Sonic Nurse. Christ, nothing compares to Washing Machine or Dirty (I reserve Daydream Nation as a separate, untouchable album). I do of course leave out of consideration NY City Ghosts...which I now like but it has taken years to get here. Anyway, The Eternal is a fantastic album with a sweeping return to the stripped down abrasive pop-punk sound of Sister and Evol, with a little Jet Set thrown in. So if you are going to write a review, don't piss about with sweeping statements about 17 years of nothing worth listening to. In those 17 years SY produced so much more than the apex of Goo. You moron. Go back and school yourself in SY. Actually listen for months on end to Washing Machine, Thousand Leaves, Murray Street, and Nurse. Only then give us your opinion about The Eternal.....

Leave a comment

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Jim DeRogatis published on June 2, 2009 10:25 AM.

Dave Matthews Band, "Big Whiskey and the GrooGrux King" (RCA) [2.5 STARS] was the previous entry in this blog.

Koko Taylor dead at 80 is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.