Chicago Sun-Times
Tuning in with Thomas Conner

Jenny Lewis, "Acid Tongue" (Warner Bros.) [3.5 STARS]

| 3 Comments | No TrackBacks

After making some of the strongest music of 2006 with her solo debut "Rabbit Fur Coat," a low-key alternative-country effort of subtle but potent charms, Jenny Lewis sounded like a completely different woman on last year's highly anticipated Rilo Kiley disc, "Under the Black Light," a pathetically soggy bid at shameless commercial pandering. Thankfully, it seems as if her partner in that setting, Blake Sennett, was the man to blame for the disappointing turn toward mainstream pop, as Lewis returns with a second solo offering that's even more low-key than its predecessor but every bit as sensual and entrancing.

More self-assured vocally, though minus the gorgeous backing harmonies of the Watson twins, the 28-year-old Lewis once again offers wry insights into her struggles with romance and personal development--"To be lonely is a habit/Like smoking or taking drugs/And I've quit them both/But man, was it rough," she sings in the title track--while effortlessly incorporating elements of some of the sounds that shaped her, from the Laurel Canyon singer-songwriters of the '70s (with echoes of Linda Ronstadt on "Pretty Bird" and the haunting opener "Black Sand") to an imagined collaboration between Randy Newman and the White Stripes (the gleeful murder ballad "Jack Killed Mom") to a mix of alt-country and progressive rock, at least in its multi-part ambition, via a nine-minutes-plus mini-suite/medley ("The Next Messiah").

The 11 songs benefit from the no-frills approach of a three-week recording session more or less live in an analog studio--even the elaborate strings of "Tryin' My Best" don't sound overly fussy--and the only misstep is a hip-hop-like roster of unnecessary cameos. Zooey Deschanel and M. Ward of She and Him make sense, but Elvis Costello sounds intrusive during his duet on "Carpetbaggers," while the black Crowes' Chris Robinson is just superfluous. But this is nit-picking.

"If you sing a song, sing a song for them," Lewis croons in "Sing A Song," the final track. "For the bats and belfry and the fairies on Main Street/For the deadbeat daddies and the Boulevard freaks/For the little girls with the carousel eyes/And the brick-a-brak finding housewives, losing their minds." Lewis' impressive strength as both a singer and a songwriter is that she makes every listener feel as if her music was crafted just for them.

No TrackBacks

TrackBack URL:


Under the Blacklight was generally well-received by critics last year. Not sure why it seems to take such a drubbing these days.

This is a really nice record. I'm not convinced (yet) that it's anywhere near as brilliant as Rabbit Fur Coat was, but the title track is definitely a finalist for my songs of the year mixtape. THIS is what that weird, slightly psychedelic Vegas sound Lewis went for on the last Rilo Kiley record should sound like. And she's got such a great voice, why waste it with such tripe?

This new record isn't exactly the follow up I expected after "Rabbit Fur Coat" but I love it anyway. Jenny can generally do no wrong in my mind. I think it's a bit underhanded to say that "Under the Blacklight" was a "pathetically shoddy bit" and that Blake Sennett had anything to do with this. Blake is anything but "mainstream", and his solo project "the elected" is amazing, brilliant, indie music that is anything but catering to the pop media. If you're going to blame anybody, blame who wrote the music. Jenny was the primary writer on Blacklight, which I think is actually a pretty decent album. Blake only helped co-write and his only solo song is "Dreamworld".

Leave a comment

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Jim DeRogatis published on September 30, 2008 1:07 PM.

Lou Reed, "Berlin: Live at St. Ann's Warehouse" (Matador) [3.5 STARS] was the previous entry in this blog.

Demo2DeRo: Mr. Russia is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.