Chicago Sun-Times
Tuning in with Thomas Conner

Album review: Destroyer, “Trouble in Dreams” (Merge) [1 STAR]

| 6 Comments | No TrackBacks

If one were looking to find a band sunk by the weight of all the worst indie-rock traits of the moment -- fey, affected vocals; orchestral filigree applied to mask melodic deficiencies; pointless complexity rubbing up against annoying faux-simplicity and wannabe Ivy League lit professor lyrical allusions -- it would be difficult to find a better candidate than Destroyer, the revolving-lineup art-rock showcase for Vancouver, Canada-based eccentric and songwriter Dan Bejar.

Although Bejar has released a staggering eight albums plus assorted other effluvia under the Destroyer name since the mid-’90s, he’s best known as a contributor of some of the finest songs on albums by the indie-rock supergroup the New Pornographers. There, his most self-indulgent and grating tendencies are mitigated by the big-band dynamic, if not checked by unofficial bandleader Carl Newman. But there are no similar filters in Destroyer, and we suffer for it.

Mellotrons chirp, EBowed guitars imitate sawing cellos, wispy backing vocals la-la-la and every time it seems as if Destroyer may rise to the moment and deliver an arty pop gem imitative of Brian Eno’s pop albums, the vibe is ruined by a self-conscious allusion to a lite-rock band like Air Supply, some over-the-top production gaffe, pretentious references to Bejar’s earlier work or our fearless leader popping back with an even more fake accent than his usual upper-crust Brit impersonation to croon a line such as, “You in white and me in gray go well tonight/So let’s linger here/This used to be my favorite palm tree/I was starving in that s--t-house, the world” from “My Favorite Year” (1993, if you’re curious), one of two especially wince-worthy prog-rock epics at the center of the disc.

No TrackBacks

TrackBack URL:


It's reviews like this that remind why you're my favorite record critic.Keep up the good work.

Agreed, this album is a total snoozer.

i've always respected jim's fiery approach although i don't always agree with him (the fiery furnaces, vampire weekend, etc) but this review really hits the spot. i get an inferiority complex when i tell other indie rock fans that destroyer is boring

Hey you guys,lay off! My brother's in Destroyer,please don't hurt his feelings.

Thanks for the warning. I was this close to hitting the store for this one ... just based on the Pornographers pedigree. Got enough affectation in my rotation right now without adding another.

You're getting old Jim, definitely getting old and stale, definitly stale, certainly old.

Leave a comment

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Jim DeRogatis published on April 2, 2008 9:25 AM.

Album review: Moby, “Last Night” (Mute/EMI) [3.5 STARS] was the previous entry in this blog.

Lollapalooza 2008 headliners confirmed is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.