Hard work helped, but agitation got blacks top coaching jobs
January 25, 2007
BY MARY MITCHELL Sun-Times Columnist
Sometimes you've got to believe in signs and wonders. Although there are too few African-American coaches in the NFL, Lovie Smith and Tony Dungy are going to the Super Bowl.
After being dissed on "American Idol," South Sider Jennifer Hudson wins a Golden Globe Award and is now up for an Oscar for Best Supporting Actress.
After being trounced in his first race for a seat in Washington, U.S. Sen. Barack Obama is being taken seriously as a candidate for the presidency.
And all of this good news is happening just in time for Black History Month.
Whenever too many good things happened at one time, my mother used to say that she hoped the world wasn't about to end.
Now I know that those periods of good favor were actually the payoff for a lot of hard work.
So it is with Smith, Dungy, Hudson, Obama and every other African American who defied the odds and actually accomplished the thing that so many said they could not.
Let's take Chicago Bears Coach Lovie Smith. He didn't just work his way up from the bottom to end up head coach. It took a lot of agitation to get him there.
Indeed, as far back as 1987, civil rights groups in Chicago were pushing professional sports teams to improve their dismal hiring practices when it came to management posts.
Threats of boycotts
The Chicago Southside Branch of the NAACP, for instance, threatened boycotts by sports fans if teams didn't respond to its campaign to increase blacks in sports management. The threat was in response to comments made by Al Campanis, the former Los Angeles Dodgers baseball executive who suggested that blacks weren't intellectually capable of managing professional teams.
Benjamin F. Hooks, then executive director of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People, demanded meetings with team owners across the country.
At the time, a spokesman for the National Football League acknowledged its responsibility in the area of minority hiring, but said progress had been made.
Despite being branded as an "opportunist," the Rev. Jesse Jackson went after Major League Baseball that same year. In a speech at then-Operation PUSH titled "Fairness in Sports Leadership" delivered shortly before July 4, Jackson offered an olive branch to owners of the professional teams, provided they move quickly to lower the invisible barriers against blacks in management, the Sun-Times reported.
Sportswriter Ray Sons noted that Jackson, indeed, was fighting for a "just cause."
"Jackson is right. The exclusion of blacks from meaningful management roles in baseball is a disgrace. Basketball's record isn't any better. Football's dearth of African Americans is an abomination," he said.
Then in 2003 came the "Rooney Rule," which was put into effect in response to a threatened lawsuit by lawyers Cyrus Mehri and the late Johnny Cochran. At the time, nearly 70 percent of the NFL's players were black, but 90 percent of the coaches were white.
The Rooney Rule says any team with a head-coaching vacancy must interview at least one minority candidate for the job, the goal being to increase the number of black head coaches. Owners weren't even required to hire a black candidate. But the first year the rule went into effect, the owner of the Detroit Lions was fined $200,000 for failing to interview a black candidate before hiring a new coach.
"It's a huge leap from an interview to a job, yet the rule is a start," Carole Slezak, a Sun-Times sports columnist, wrote at the time. "Who knew it would be so darn hard for a team to comply? No wonder there are only three black head coaches in the NFL," she said. "If the lack of black coaches doesn't convince you of the need for the Rooney Rule, the Lions' behavior should," Slezak wrote.
Love of game doesn't seem to be enough
Before taking over the Bears' head coaching job three years ago this month, Smith was a defensive coordinator for the St. Louis Rams -- a steppingstone to the top slot.
When he was hired by the Bears, Smith became the fifth black active head coach in the NFL, along with Herman Edwards of the New York Jets, Marvin Lewis of the Cincinnati Bengals, Tony Dungy of the Indianapolis Colts and Dennis Green of the Arizona Cardinals.
"Me being in this position will open the eyes of a lot of young African-American men to see what you can accomplish if you have a goal," Smith said when he was introduced to Chicago.
But young black men also need to know that without the Rooney Rule, Smith may not have even gotten an interview.
Unfortunately, too often it takes more than the love of the game to get into the game.
In this case, it took agitation.
Now we know. Discrimination wasn't just cheating the players, it was cheating the fans.
