Marcus Jordan Naysayers Need To Back Off

| 2 Comments | No TrackBacks

By Roy & Harv Schmidt

No high school basketball player in Illinois has been under more constant scrutiny than Whitney Young's Marcus Jordan. Such is the case when you are the son of the greatest basketball player who has ever lived. Expectations become too high and often end up being unrealistic. After watching Jordan at the Proviso West Holiday Tournament, our message to the critics is quite simple--it is time to silence yourselves!

The bottom line is that Jordan can play. He has proven that to us whenever he has been on the court. We will offer more specific evidence along those lines as we go along. However, before we go any further, let us analyze why Jordan seems to be the subject of much debate when it comes to where he ranks among the top prospects in Illinois from the class of 2009 and why some have even suggested that he may be overrated.

In our opinion the biggest reason why Jordan has attracted some naysayers is because during the first month of this season, no other player on the Whitney Young team has been more affected by the 11 man rotation that head coach Tyrone Slaughter has consistently employed. As a result, Jordan's playing time has been limited and his numbers have not been as productive as some might expect. But when you play on a team that sports more overall talent and depth than any other team in the state, this comes with the territory.

All of this started to change at the recently concluded Proviso West tournament. Not only did Jordan get significant playing time, he made every minute that he was on the floor count. There is no doubt in our minds that Jordan was clearly the difference in Whitney Young's 59-45 semifinal win over New Trier. In that contest, Jordan turned in his best performance of the season thus far, as he wound up with 14 points and 12 rebounds. Jordan was named to the Proviso West all-tournament team as a result of his efforts.

What also made Jordan's outing at Proviso West most significant was that it marked the first time this season that he, 6'2 junior Chris Colvin and 5'9 point guard A.J. Rompza were all on the court together for a substantial amount of time. We believe this is something that Whitney Young needs to stick with in its quest to win the class 4A state championship. Jordan finally appears to be getting more comfortable with Whitney Young's system after transferring from Loyola Academy in Wilmette, IL this past summer and when all three of the aforementioned players were on the floor, one could see the difference with respect to the team's overall chemistry.

From a recruiting standpoint, we are absolutely amazed that at the present time Jordan has received no scholarship offers from high major D1 programs, at least none that we are aware of. Once again, keep in mind that Marcus Jordan is the son of the greatest basketball player who has ever lived. With that being said and knowing that they are constantly in the spotlight, it would come as no surprise to find out that the Jordan family is keeping Marcus' recruitment extremely close to the vest.

So where does Marcus Jordan rank amongst the top 2009 prospects in Illinois? In our minds, he should be a part of any discussion that deals with the top five or six juniors in the state. He has all of the physical tools--he is strong and athletic. As a result, he consistently gets to the basket and is tough on the glass. While he is a bit streaky when it comes to shooting, he has shown that he has 3-point range. And last but certainly not least he plays hard and is unselfish.

Furthermore, when one considers the fact that all of the players who we would rank among the top five in Illinois from the 2009 class are up and down and tend to be inconsistent, it simply enhances our belief that Jordan deserves to be included in the team photo. On that note, here are our current rankings of the top five prospects in Illinois from the class of 2009 based upon the conclusion of holiday tournament action:
1) Brandon Paul 6'3 2G Gurnee (Warren)
2) Joe Bertrand 6'4 2G Sterling (H.S.)
3) Chris Colvin 6'2 PG Chicago (Whitney Young)
4) D.J. Richardson 6'3 2G Peoria (Central)
5) Marcus Jordan 6'2 2G Chicago (Whitney Young)

No TrackBacks

TrackBack URL:


Author's Note: it is not my habit to criticize high school kids for their athletic play. However, someone needs to call out the various media outlets (internet, print, TV) regarding their coverage of Marcus Jordan and the Whitney Young basketball team. My apologies if any feelings are hurt.


Your introduction says that Marcus Jordan is under more scrutiny and saddled with higher and more unrealistic expectations than any player in Illinois. I agree and would go further: Jordan is currently regarded by many fans in the stands (perhaps a majority) as receiving undue media attention at the expense of his teammates and the players on opposing teams.

I recorded last weekend's Proviso West championship game and gave a copy to friend. I received this e-mail reply from him:
"Only complaint was the announcers mentioned MJ too, too, too much! "Oooh, look even Michael Jordan is standing up!", "Oooh, look, there's Michael Jordan smiling.", "Oooh, look, there's Michael Jordan...". And then it was all about Marcus Jordan. Is he really that good? Would he even be noticed if he wasn't Jordan's kid? I know he got hurt and all, but he wasn't all that impressive. A division I-AA player at the moment."

So yes, there is a problem here. Unfortunately, your message that "Jordan Neasayers" need to "silence themselves" is precisely opposite of what needs to happen. It is the "Jordan Yeasayers" making all the noise and they need to stop it. Consider the following points:

1. Whitney Young was going to be very good this year, even without Marcus Jordan and Jake Hager transferring in. Anyone who had seen the Dolphins play at last year's (2006) Proviso West tourney understood that they would be good down the road. Jordan and Hager simply increased the roster depth on an already deep team.

2. Whitney Young's senior backcourt trio of Hall, Kenner and Rompza are the backbone of the team and deserve more recognition. Hall and Rompza played as freshmen on the 2005 team that beat Washington for the city soph title and together with Kenner have led Whitney Young's varsity to the point it's at today. This season each of them has almost single-handedly kept the Dolphins in a game and gotten the close win. Can you say the same of Marcus Jordan (I don't think the 14 point win against New Trier qualifies)? By your own ranking, Jordan is not even the best underclassman on this team.

3. Deja Vu, all over again: high school basketball fans can't shake the nagging memory of last year's Loyola Academy team, featuring (ahem) Jeffrey and Marcus Jordan. Remember the local media coverage and lofty top-five rankings in both the Sun-Times and Trib? Remember the subsequent coverage in USA Today and on ESPN? Remember the national ranking? Remember when they played Indianapolis North Central on national TV and lost 88 to 47? Refresh my memory, did Gordon single-handedly outscore the entire Loyola team? How many points did Jeffrey and Marcus Jordan come away with?

4. Your ranking of the top 5 juniors illustrates my objection to the coverage Marcus Jordan receives. First, please note that that all five players are either committed to Illinois (Paul, Bertrand, Richardson) or playing for Whitney Young (Colvin, Jordan); congratulations coaches Weber and Slaughter, you've cornered the market!!! Second, you're saying that Jordan outranks Diamond Taylor (St. Joes), Xavier Humphrey (Fenwick), Eriq Harris and Darius Smith (Marshall), Michael Haynes (Washington), Jeremy Jones and Brandon Orange (Simeon), among others; congratulations Marcus Jordan!!!

Marcus Jordan is a pretty good basketball player playing for a very good Whitney Young team. His teammates seem to like him and he willingly accepts his role coming off the bench. I wish him the best but I'm pretty sure that he won't be able live up to the media's expectations of him, yours included.

Thanks for hearing me out.

MJ is def better then X, Eriq, Darius, and Diamond...idk bout bertrand, def not DJ or BP

ya diggggg

Mj top 5 no dought

Leave a comment

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Roy & Harv Schmidt published on January 3, 2008 9:36 AM.

Why Dillard Is Player Of The Year Frontrunner was the previous entry in this blog.

Crandall Head Makes It Official is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.