The City/Suburban Hoops Report concludes its list of 10 things it learned this high school basketball season. Here is the final top 10 list.
#1: It won't happen but ... It's time for a shot clock
If you would have asked the Hoops Report five years ago or two years ago -- or even 12 months ago -- it would have voted "No" on a shot clock for high school basketball.
In a City/Suburban Hoops Report survey conducted just two years ago for the City/Suburban Hoops Report publication, I agreed with high school coaches in voting "No" on a shot clock. A total of 126 high school coaches were surveyed, with 58 voting for the addition of a shot clock and 68 voting against a shot clock.
Although the vote totals were relatively close, I was surprised at the final results. I suspected a shot clock would get more favorable reviews in this day and age of high school basketball. Maybe coaches, like myself, would feel differently now, just two years later.
"I do not favor a shot clock. Kids take enough bad shots already," said Von Steuben coach Vince Carter at the time of the survey two years ago.
"No to a shot clock -- unless we at least try it first," said Conant coach Tom McCormack. "I wouldn't want to see it rammed down our throats like some other things."
Added coach Mike Flaherty of Mt. Carmel, "No. It allows coaches with less talent to still find a way to compete."
I'm certainly not in favor of the 24-second shot clock the NBA uses. And though I could live with college basketball's 35-second shot clock, for high school basketball I would prefer a 45-second shot clock.
The 45-second shot clock would still give high school coaches and teams plenty of time to run their offense and various sets. To a degree, patience could still be preached. But the addition of a shot clock would prevent many of the issues that have slowed the game up.
Here is a scenario I never want to see again: Team A has possession coming out of the half and is up 25-21 to start the third quarter. Team B is on defense, down four, packed in a zone. Thus, the holding of the ball on the hip near halfcourt by Team A point guard begins -- for minutes at a time, even an entire quarter. Student sections boo, the flow of the game is lost and everyone in the gym, from the players to the fans, all agree: This is not what we signed up for.
I'm all for being smart and patient, holding for the last shot of a quarter or a half and seeing a team execute. But I would be just fine seeing that for the final 40-50 seconds of a quarter or half rather than for 75 seconds or two minutes.
Plus, I would like a little more strategy and excitement infused into the game. The final two or three minutes of regulation would be so much more intriguing and appealing with a shot clock. The shot clock would somewhat diminish the constant fouling and sending teams to the line repeatedly down the stretch.
And I don't want to hear anything more about leveling the playing field, that a shot clock caters to the more talented, athletic team. We already leveled the playing field with four-class basketball.
The biggest obstacle to a shot clock, though, likely isn't the strategy ramifications but the implementation of it.
For starters, it would be costly to school districts and athletic budgets that are already skimping any way they can. We're talking more than just shot clocks on the two baskets in the main gym. A court or two in fieldhouse courts or a second gym within a high school would need to be equipped with shot clocks as lower level games and holiday tournaments often take place in those gyms.
We haven't even discussed all the high school summer leagues and shootouts (and AAU?) that are played on multiple courts in the offseason. At the recent Hoop Mountain Shootout at West Aurora last week there were seven games being played on seven separate courts at one time. You can't just not play with a shot clock in the offseason.
Then there is the added cost of paying for another worker -- the shot clock operator -- for every boys and girls basketball game at the freshman, sophomore, junior varsity and varsity levels.
Plus, there is going to have to be some type of shot clock training. My biggest fear with the addition of a shot clock in high school is seeing just who's finger is controlling it at the scorer's table.
Former Brother Rice coach Pat Richardson, who stepped down this past spring after 24 seasons as head coach, pointed out the potential issues two years ago in the survey.
"I can't even begin to imagine the problems we would have at the scorer's table as far as starting the shot clock late, when to reset it, etc. -- especially at the lower levels."
Very true. You're not going to be able to just throw anyone into that job, especially for regional and sectional games.
There are certainly some implementation issues and cost factors, which will likely prevent the shot clock coming to a high school near you anytime soon. But for the high school game itself -- and if all the logistics could be dealt with -- I'm ready for it.
#2: Illinois prep hoops needs a downstate power
Illinois high school basketball is better when there is a powerful, big-named program outside the Chicago area.
We're not talking a great team here and there. O'Fallon made two trips to Peoria, won a couple of trophies and has been a strong program in southern Illinois, finishing second in 2007 and fourth in 2010. Champaign Centennial had a terrific two-year run, winning a state championship in 2009 and finishing fourth in 2010. Rock Island, though west rather than "downstate," won a 3A title in 2011, while Peoria Central won a 3A championship in 2012.
There have been a few others here and there who've made a dent. But it's not the same as having that thoroughbred program with staying power, producing elite players on a regular basis and possessing a certain aura about them.
One of the appetizing parts of Illinois prep basketball that's missing right now is a dominant Quincy-type team, an East St. Louis Lincoln power from the 1980s or a Peoria Manual dynasty in the 1990s.
And while Dick Van Scyoc's powerful Manual teams from 1982-1991 didn't win a state championship, it was a State Finals regular (five trips to Champaign) with three state trophies and a long lineup of familiar players and talent being pumped through the program.
When there is a dynamic program with staying power from outside the Chicago area, it just makes Illinois high school basketball that much more appealing, exciting and intriguing.
People were so charged up in the 1980s to get to Champaign and get an up-close look at those great, athletic teams out of East St. Louis. Coach Bennie Lewis' teams were so far out of the scope of the Chicago area during the winter months, the anticipation of getting a glimpse of those juggernaut teams started to build when state tournament play began. It started with the Todd Porter-led teams in the early 1980s and just got better later in the decade with LaPhonso Ellis and Cuonzo Martin.
The Manual teams in the 1990s were must-see for high school basketball fans as the Rams began their march towards four straight state championships. Even the Peoria Central teams from 10 years ago, fueled by NBA Lottery Pick Shaun Livingston, supercharged the prep hoops scene as it went 62-3 and won back-to-back state championships.
Now, with Peoria basketball in a tailspin when it comes to high-level, individual talent, you wonder just where our next downstate power will come from and when it will be.
#3: The Class of 2016 has a long way to go
There's no sin in letting young kids develop at their own pace. Less hype early on in a high school player's career is always better.
But when it comes to the Class of 2016 in Illinois, it's been awhile since there was this little of an impact at the varsity level by a freshmen group as a whole. Once an absolute rarity back in the 1970s, 1980s and even into the early 1990s, freshmen contributing at the varsity level has now become the norm. This past year the impact was minuscule.
Current high school players like Jabari Parker at Simeon, Jahlil Okafor at Whitney Young, Cliff Alexander at Curie, Jalen Brunson at Stevenson, Tyler Ulis at Marian Catholic, Billy Garrett, Jr. at Morgan Park, Morris Dunnigan at Joliet West, Roosevelt Smart at Palatine, Evan Boudreaux at Lake Forest, Robert Knar at Mundelein, Jaylon Tate at De La Salle, Charles and Dominique Matthews at St. Rita, Milik Yarbrough at Zion-Benton, St. Charles East's Kendall Stephens and many others all made significant impacts at the varsity level as freshmen.
This season? There were a few freshmen here and there that contributed and made various impacts around the state this past winter, but it's been nothing to the degree we've grown accustomed to over the past decade.
Times have changed. Today, many parents are starting to expect their son to play varsity basketball as a freshman, even sometimes choosing a high school to attend based on that opportunity.
Even high school coaches are now looking for freshmen who might be able to contribute. There just wasn't a lot of that happening this past season.
#4: Cliff Alexander has turned the corner and become an alpha dog
There are legit high-major prospects. Then among those legit high-major prospects there are the alpha dogs. Those players that combine the promise, potential, production, the must-have qualities college coaches covet and the alpha dog instincts where they know who and what they are as a player.
A year ago, as a sophomore, Whitney Young's Jahlil Okafor joined Simeon's Jabari Parker on that alpha dog level. This year Cliff Alexander did the same -- and continues to in the early going of the 2013 club basketball circuit.
The Curie big man went from a promising, high-major big-man "prospect" to an absolutely dominating force. His confidence grew, his production became more consistent and what he did on the floor left you saying, "There just aren't many of THOSE type of guys around."
A big, strong, powerful, athletic post who blocks shots, rebounds, runs the floor and dunks everything, Alexander will be scary as he continues to develop offensively. In this era of hard-to-find talented big men, Alexander moved into the minuscule percentage of absolutely must-have, program-changing recruits for the small percentage of college programs that even have a legitimate shot at him.
#5: Illinois high school basketball is becoming a two-class society
We've heard how the middle class has been lost in America, how the rich get richer. We might be on the verge of that happening in Illinois prep basketball. Some will say it's already happened.
There is the Chicago Public League, most notably Simeon, Whitney Young and Morgan Park, and then everyone else.
With Simeon leading the way, these three city powers have stockpiled championships in recent years and long-lasting talent.
Prep hoops in Illinois is starting to resemble women's college basketball, where the same teams dominate year after year. When the women's Final Four takes place, you come to just expect at least two or three of the same teams among Connecticut, Tennessee, Notre Dame and Stanford to be playing in it.
Over the past eight seasons in the state's largest class of basketball, Simeon and Whitney Young have won seven of the eight championships. (Richards won the 4A title in 2008--but Simeon dipped down to 3A that season and played Marshall in the 3A state title game.) In addition, Simeon and Whitney Young both have a state runner-up trophy in the last six years.
This year Simeon won its fourth straight title and sixth championship in the past eight years. If Simeon had lost, odds are Whitney Young would have been your Class 4A champion. Simeon knocked off Whitney Young in the sectional championship.
In Class 3A, Morgan Park simply wasn't going to lose to anyone. The Mustangs proved that by the mockery they made of the other 3A teams throughout March.
The jump Morgan Park has made from respectable program to power since coach Nick Irvin took over has ramped up the city's stranglehold on prep hoops in this state. Since Irvin took over in 2008, Morgan Park has averaged 26 wins a season and now has a state championship.
And next year? Each one of these three powers will be back with more firepower. Whitney Young, with the return of the nation's top-ranked player, Jahlil Okafor, will be favored to win 4A. Simeon boasts a bundle of young talent and will remain a major threat over the next three seasons. And Morgan Park, even with heavy graduation losses, will likely be one of the favorites to repeat in Class 3A when the season begins.
#6: Jalen Brunson is who I thought he was
A year ago in this very space, in this exact blog idea--10 things I learned this season (the 2011-2012 season version)--Jalen Brunson was declared the best freshman in the state.
There were some critics, many who questioned that assertion, scoffed at the idea a kid from the suburbs, in Lincolnshire, of all places, could be the best player in the freshman class in Illinois. Understandable. Hoop fanatics just want players to go out and earn their respect.
There is sometimes personal second-guessing when you develop the type of basketball crush the Hoops Report had on Brunson, as described in this blog from December.
That hoops crush happened quickly, as in the first time it took in the young star the summer before his freshman year of high school at the UIC Team Camp. That's when you know. As there is with all special talents, there was something different about this player at that young of an age -- and the very first time you watched him play.
Now, nearly two years later, no surprise with this: Brunson is still the best player in his class, the best sophomore in the state.
Both St. Rita's Charles Matthews and Simeon's D.J. Williams are ranked higher nationally and are terrific prospects at the same stage of their young careers. Matthews has made quite an impression as a freshman and sophomore, while Williams is just beginning to blossom into the player he can be. In fact, when projecting down the road with that magical word "upside," some would argue that Matthews and Williams may get an edge over Brunson.
But Brunson, the 6-2 Stevenson point guard, is just so complete at this age. It's remarkable, really, when you look at the production and impact he made over the course of the entire season. There is no denying that right now he's the most complete, consistent and productive sophomore in the class who impacts games in different ways every trip down the floor.
Then he went and dazzled national scouts and those who haven't had much of a chance to see him this past weekend at the Swish 'N Dish in Wisconsin. While playing with the Mac Irvin Fire, he played up an age group and still did his thing in impressive fashion.
There are many factors that went into Stevenson finishing second in the state, but the biggest reason is pretty clear--Brunson. And when it comes to the pleasure of watching someone play basketball the way it's supposed to be played, with an understanding, discipline and the talent he possesses, it's easy to appreciate the brand of basketball this kid brings to the floor.
#7: The Class of 2014 is worth the hype.
With massive attention thrown Jahlil Okafor's way as early as 8th grader--and the Whitney Young big fella living up to the expectations through his high school career--the Class of 2014 has received a heavy dose of hype and college interest from the get-go.
Soon, Curie's Cliff Alexander joined Okafor among the top 10 national talents in the Class of 2014, while Normal U-High's Keita Bates-Diop became a consensus top 25 prospect in the country. The class had its star power at the top, so the hype ensued.
But what materialized over the course of this past season is a group of juniors that solidified themselves as legitimate prospects. Yes, the eye-catching, high-level talent at the top is impressive, but the class also has tremendous Division I depth. Right now the Hoops Report envisions not just 30-plus Division I prospects, but 30-plus mid-major Division I prospects.
The most recent Rivals.com player rankings has 10 players from Illinois ranked among its top 100 players in the Class of 2014 and 14 among the top 150.
While the Hoops Report doesn't always agree with the national rankings when it comes to players it watches the most here in Illinois, the fact 10 percent of the top 100 players in the country are from Illinois is an eye-opener.
And although the Hoops Report may not truly believe there are more than two dozen legit high-major players in the junior class, as is being projected, it won't be a surprise if that number ends up signing with programs in high-major conferences next November.
The Class of 2011 in Illinois was loaded, the best this state has produced since 1998. The Class of 2014 is on track to be better and deeper than 2011.
#8: Malachi Nix was the most underappreciated senior
While it's true you could replace Malachi Nix's name here with a number of different "underappreciated" players from this 2012-2013 season--New Trier's Steven Cook, Oswego's Elliot McGaughey, Benet's Pat McInerney and Lemont's Juozas Balciunas to name a few--and I wouldn't argue with you, the 5-6 point guard gets the nod. He's just done so much as a player for a once-downtrodden Niles North basketball program.
In fact, he's been so influential that Niles North basketball may have to count years by using the abbreviation BN--"before Nix."
Prior to Nix entering the halls of Niles North, the basketball program won 34 games the previous eight seasons. This past year alone Nix and the Vikings won 27.
Before Nix, the Niles North basketball program had won one regional title and produced two 20-win seasons--in the previous 50 years. During Nix's sophomore, junior and senior years, Niles North averaged 24 wins a year, won three straight regional championships and won the school's first-ever sectional title. Yes, "BN" works for Niles North basketball.
"First and foremost, he is a competitor and a winner," says Niles North coach Glenn Olson of his star point guard. "People question his size, but I have watched him every day and realize how little of a factor his size is."
Even with all the team success (84 career wins, 3 straight regional titles, 1 sectional championship and two CSL North titles) and despite significant numbers Nix put up (Nix scored 44 in a win over Morton), he's been underappreciated, somewhat overlooked.
Nix didn't receive the headlines or attention other top guards in the senior class have received. He didn't land on the Chicago Sun-Times all-area team. The recruiting interest has been tepid.
Nix graduates with 1,532 career points after averaging 18 points a game as a senior. He's also the career leader in steals with 215.
Loyola Academy coach Tom Livatino watched Nix beat his Ramblers team twice during their 22-6 season, including a regional final loss to end the season as Nix poured in a whopping 39 points.
"He's a warrior with a toughness and a will to win," says Livatino, who says Nix reminds him of a former player he coached at Lincoln Park, Northwestern standout point guard Michael Thompson. "I would not be concerned about his size. You can't stay in front of him and has a knack for scoring. He's relentless on defense."
Editor's Note: Nix recently committed to and will sign with Fairleigh Dickinson.
#9: Simeon's place nationally is solidified
Rob Smith really doesn't need any further validation that his goal of becoming a national program has been accomplished, but here is some anyway.
You know the notion of Simeon being recognized nationally is valid when you're at a swim up bar in a resort pool in Mexico and, without any provoking, Simeon basketball pops up in the conversation. When a man sipping a Bahama Mama finds out you're from Chicago, he brings up -- of all things -- Simeon.
The conversation with this Boston sports fan -- who I can't even put in the avid sports fan category since he forgot his very own Celtic Rajon Rondo was out with an injury (Although he was a wee bit inebriated) -- began casually. But within minutes of Boston/Chicago conversation, he brings up Jabari Parker, how he was aware of Parker and Simeon with all the media attention thrown their way, and "Isn't that where Derrick Rose went to high school as well?"
Simeon is arguably -- no, not arguably anymore -- Simeon basketball IS, nationally, this state's most recognizable high school athletic program in history. Prior to Simeon basketball, that distinction probably went to Frank Lenti and Mt. Carmel football when the Caravan played in 10 state championships from 1989-2003, winning nine, and were prominently mentioned nationally.
Now it's Simeon, thanks to Derrick Rose, Jabari Parker, mass media exposure, national TV appearances and championships. The Wolverines reached the national level prior to this season, but the program reached new, greater heights during this 2012-2013 campaign.
#10: The IHSA needs set rules for state tournament dates and cancellations
Now that we have been reminded that snowstorms can occur in March, can the IHSA -- no, the IHSA must -- put something in place to properly handle the cancellation of regional and sectional games?
The fact teams had to play sectional semifinal games Thursday night, while the other sectional winner had the night off while waiting for its sectional final opponent, is ludicrous.
Every step of the way along the state tournament trail becomes more taxing and emotionally draining. There is no question there was a distinct disadvantage for any team that played and won the Thursday night sectional game this year.
While one sectional semifinal winner had the luxury of "coming back down" emotionally from its win, having a night off and preparing for the sectional final with an actual practice, the other winner had to come back and play less than 24 hours later the following night for a sectional championship.
You can say teams play back-to-back nights all season or they do it for the State Finals in Peoria the very next weekend. But EVERYONE is doing it then, not just one of the two teams, so it remains competitively fair.
These high school teams--the players and the coaches--put in so much time and energy, both out of season and during the season to prepare for this moment. The least we can do is when games mean the most and they are playing for what they've worked so hard for is give them all a balanced playing field and an equal, fair shot.
The IHSA can claim this was the only way due to scheduling conflicts and availability with sectional sites, facilities and workers. Maybe scheduling snafus were an issue at a sectional site or two--I know the Class 3A sectional at Nazareth was one (the sectional was moved to Riverside-Brookfield as a result).
I also know I called three sectional hosts and asked if moving the championship game to Saturday night would have been a problem. Each one said there would be no problem in moving the title game one day back.
But the bigger question is why isn't there something more concrete already in place for situations like this?
I guess that shouldn't be a surprise since the IHSA leaves regional scheduling to the discretion of the host school. Huh? This is a whole other story, but look at the various regional scheduling around the state. They're all different from regional to regional with the opportunity (power) to add competitive advantages when they see fit. Why wouldn't they all be uniform across the state?
When it comes to hosting a sectional, would it be that difficult to put in writing that sectional hosts must, in the rare event there is a cancellation, have their gym available all week, including Saturday night?
What took place this past year can't happen again. And I would think every high school coach would agree.
Follow Joe Henricksen and the City/Suburban Hoops Report on Twitter @joehoopsreport