By Joe Henricksen

Little room for error in 3A hoops

| 2 Comments | No TrackBacks

By Joe Henricksen

There probably isn't anyone who hates the idea of four classes in Illinois high school basketball more than Joe

Henricksen and the City/Suburban Hoops Report. Oh, there are plenty of people -- feverish fans, media members

and high school coaches -- who hate it just as much, but no one could possibly despise it more. And while I refuse

to accept it, the least I can do as part of a New Year's resolution is try to make the best of it.


In trying to make the best of it, I have tried to look at the positive. The only positive thus far -- and please don't even

try to give me this gives more kids and communities opportunities to win, blah, blah, blah -- is that if everything falls

just right, the Class 3A Final Four in Peoria this March could be a lot of fun. The bad part, however, as pointed out in

the most recent issue of the City/Suburban Hoops Report, is there is little room for error. If one of the big dogs fall

early, there are really no talented teams to step in and take their place as a true, legitimate state championship

caliber team. Thus, we have to pray for zero upsets this March in Class 3A.


As of right now in Class 3A, there are three true state powers -- Simeon, Marshall and Decatur Eisenhower. After

that there isn't a team that would be a legitimate state title contender in any other year. But now? Add good -- but

not great -- St. Joseph, Champaign Central, Washington and Peoria Richwoods -- to the 3A mix.


Here is a warning: the regional championship games, the drama-filled sectionals and must-see supersectional

matchups we've all seen in the past won't be there this March in Class 3A. The state tournament as a whole -- in

Class 3A -- will be dreadful. But being the positive guy that I am, the Final Four in Peoria could be pretty special.

How you ask?


First, the Big Three of Simeon, Marshall and Decatur Eisenhower are all in different brackets. These three are

clearly three of the five or six top teams in Illinois regardless of class. There is the intrigue of a possible Simeon-

Eisenhower rematch. Eisenhower handed Simeon a close loss back in December. There will be Division I talent

galore, headed by Purdue-bound Lewis Jackson of Eisenhower, the Illinois State tandem of Eisenhower's Jeremy

Robinson and Simeon's Kenyon Smith, Illinois recruit Stan Simpson of Simeon, Ryan Hare of Marshall, one of the top

unsigned players in the state, and a host of others that will be playing Division I basketball in the near future.


But back to the problem. If any of these three were to lose, get upset on one of those off nights where everything

goes wrong, which we have seen so many times in the past, the drop in talent and overall interest is quick and

pretty sad. Typically when that happens in the past, another talented team takes advantage and rolls into Peoria.

Not this year. The lone exception is probably St. Joseph, with talented underclassmen in junior Diamond Taylor and

sophomore DeAndre McCamey. St. Joe's could give Marshall a scare in a sectional battle.


The fourth team in the Class 3A Final Four will likely come out of the Peoria area. And from a selfish standpoint the

choice would be Washington. If Washington's Matt Roth, the greatest three-point shooter in state history and

Indiana recruit, joins the other three powers on the big stage, it would be awfully fun and entertaining. Plus, fans

could see what all the hype is for Washington junior guard Dyricus Simms-Edwards, who together with Roth form

one of the top backcourts in Illinois. Limestone and Peoria Richwoods may have something to say about

Washington getting out of the sectional, but from a fan's perspective Washington is the choice, even if it's not a

team at the same level as the three aforementioned powers.


So putting a positive spin on this whole four-class, 3A basketball thing, a dream Final Four could still materialize

with Simeon, Marshall, Decatur Eisenhower and Washington. And throw in four 4A schools of Farragut, Zion-

Benton, Homewood-Flossmoor and Batavia? Now those are eight quality teams. It's just too bad they wouldn't all be

playing for one legitimate state title instead of two.

To subscribe or for more information on the City/Suburban Hoops Report, now in its 13th year of publication, call (630)-408-6709 or e-mail hoopsreport@yahoo.com

No TrackBacks

TrackBack URL: http://blogs.suntimes.com/cgi-bin/mt-tb.cgi/5962

2 Comments

Joe, I don't know, but I think I might hate it at least as much as you do.

http://www2.pjstar.com/index.php?/preps/article/P0/

Joe and Nick,

I hate the four class system !!!

Anyone who cares about IHSA basketball should read the Peoria Journal Star article that Nick provided a link to above.

In a nutshell: Chicago area teams are placed into seeded sectional brackets, in order to assure that the best teams do not eliminate each other in the first two rounds of the tournament. Downstate teams are placed in unseeded geographical regionals in order to reduce travel time, meaning that the some of the best teams find themselves playing each other in the first two rounds of the tournament. The "new improved" four class tournament requires two sets of rules, one for Chicago schools and one for downstate schools!!! Thank you, Marty Hickman!!!

Please note that these rule differences in assigning opponents did not exist in the two class system.

The unmistakable conclusions are this: the IHSA boys basketball tournament both provided a uniform playoff structure and entertained fans statewide for one hundred years. Marty Hickman's four class tournament requires different sets of rules for different parts of the state. As a result, basketball fans are prevented from seeing the best teams square off in a fairly designed tournament system.

Leave a comment

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Joe Henricksen published on January 11, 2008 8:13 AM.

Catholic League makes statement over the holidays was the previous entry in this blog.

Lesser names rise, bigger names fall in '09 is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.