The mesmerizing masterpiece "Memento" - Our far-flung correspondents

The mesmerizing masterpiece "Memento"

| 19 Comments

1_13.jpg• Omar Moore, San Francisco


In the wake of the disappointing "Shutter Island", it's especially gratifying to look back at Christopher Nolan's feature film "Memento" (2001), an indie mystery starring Guy Pearce as a San Francisco man in Los Angeles suffering from anterograde amnesia, or short-term memory loss.

Within seconds Leonard Shelby can't keep a thought in his head, the same way one with a bad digestive tract can't hold down food. Memory evaporates like cotton candy.


To retain a semblance of memory, Leonard scribbles notes constantly, checking the tattoos that cover his body for the faintest sign of recognition of his life. "Memento" certainly isn't a comedy like "The Hangover"; it's an entertaining meditation of the lead character's visual and psychological discombobulating. "Memento" is often filmmaking accomplished on a genius level.


In this landscape of earth tones and blues, we know that at least one person has been killed. Polaroid snapshots are significant markers in a film where every image, especially the previous one, counts.



Told -- or more precisely presented -- in reverse chronological order, "Memento" is a construction of two stories; one shot in color in the "present" world in which Leonard is surrounded by the people in his life, and the other a timeless black and white documentary-like story of an isolated Leonard anguished by lack of memory and haunted by fear and anxiety. Each scene is an episode flipped backwards, so that by the time the scene concludes we progress closer to the beginning of the story. As written by Mr. Nolan and based on his brother Jonathan's original short story "Memento Mori", the film makes its audience work while entertaining and enveloping it in its intricacies.


03.jpg


"Memento" was shot in just over three weeks in and around Los Angeles in 1999. Mr. Nolan's drama is ironic, comedic and violent, but every act is vital to completing a cinematic jigsaw puzzle of who you can and cannot trust. The very sentence you are reading right now may confuse: "Memento" as a film is a theater of manipulation but the devices engineered to conceive the effect of the film aren't necessarily manipulative in and of themselves. Dody Dorn's phenomenal editing is the film's greatest strength. Many visual clues fuel this noir-like drama and the clever, cheeky dialogue in Mr. Nolan's screenplay present an abundance of them. On second viewing the clues are glaring. You wonder how on earth you missed them the first time.


There's a playful déjà vu that pulses throughout "Memento" and on a lesser level a subtle commentary on Los Angeles and its more opportunistic denizens, such as a hotel operator, who tells Leonard about something he did. The recounting of the deed will bring laughs; such is the wry humor that underlines the film. For all its weightiness, "Memento" doesn't consume itself with melancholy, even if it takes itself seriously. The film's music score (David Julyan) evokes a somber undercurrent but acts as a subterranean voice of conscience accompanying Leonard throughout. On occasion the score's synthesized notes play like subliminal blips of Leonard's defragmented mind, as he struggles to make sense of things. Mr. Julyan's score faintly echoes such movie scores as "Blade Runner", composed by Vangelis, who also created the score for "Chariots of Fire". Mr. Julyan also scored Mr. Nolan's debut feature film "Following" (1998).

09.jpg


The film, its lead character and the director are never a step ahead of the audience. We wonder as Leonard wonders. We are puzzled, confounded and intrigued. Who are the people we see? Are they props? Are they figments of the protagonist's imagination? Are they manipulators? And who exactly is Leonard talking to on the phone? This last question is as vexing as: what was in the suitcase emitting the rich golden glow in "Pulp Fiction"?


Leonard is excellently portrayed by Guy Pearce, who was seen in the 2009 films "The Hurt Locker" and "The Road". In "Memento" Mr. Pearce looks like David Bowie did in his 1983 music video "Let's Dance", with a very similar blond hairstyle and angular features. Mr. Bowie's music video was shot in Australia, and Mr. Pearce, who was born in England, was raised in Australia from age three. Perhaps it is more than mere coincidence that Mr. Bowie's song "Something in the Air" plays over the end credits of "Memento".


"Memento" cinematographer and frequent Nolan collaborator Wally Pfister decorates the film in shades of blue and the photography is often visually arresting. Blue is an essential element, consistently tied to Leonard's perspectives on life. Blue is associated with cool, sadness and truth. In the story shot in color virtually every frame with Leonard in it has a tinge of blue, right down to Mr. Pearce's blue eyes.


The story Mr. Pfister shot in color represents the realm in which facts are either deduced or discovered. The story shot in black and white represents opinion and conjecture that are obviously subjective and uncontested, yet sometimes shot in with an objective point of view.


12.jpg

Though Leonard occupies much of Mr. Nolan's film, there are two other important players in "Memento". One is Joe Pantoliano, who plays Teddy, an undercover police officer trying to shepherd Leonard through his identity crisis. The other is Carrie-Anne Moss as Natalie, a bartender who also tries to assist Leonard through his ordeal. Both are very good, and their characters keep the proceedings interesting. Teddy and Natalie are mysterious beings.


Just as mysterious is the amazing two-disc DVD limited edition of "Memento", released in 2002 in the U.S. The limited edition box is presented as a clipboard psychiatric file application/report on Leonard. Wrapped in a light blue, teal-like color, the package is supplemented with handwritten notes and charts. The original theatrical R-rated release is on disc one, with Mr. Nolan's audio commentary, which briefly begins with a backwards, sped-up voice before we eventually hear Mr. Nolan talking. All of this however, is not before having to endure a frustrating test in which you have to identify and remember words that flash furiously before you on the screen. The words are then presented in rows. (To see the film, select the word "watch".)


02.jpg


Disc two is the goldmine for "Memento" fanatics. There's the director's shooting script, trailers, Jonathan Nolan's original story, and among other features, a special "Easter egg" surprise, which allows you to watch "Memento" in chronological order, starting with much of the black and white story. To access it you will need to select the clock from the group of two dozen objects. The letter C should be selected as the option for five successive questions. A set of four comic strip-like drawings of a woman with her car will appear. You are asked to rearrange them in the correct order. (The correct sequence is pictures 3, 4, 1 and 2.) The film then plays in chronological order, cheekily beginning with a manipulation of the end credits. Jason Bovberg of DVD Talk presents a helpful, detailed explanation of how to access all the features on both discs in his 2003 article about the limited edition 2-disc DVD edition.


Overall, Christopher Nolan's work chronicles isolation, duality, perception and the realm of senses. All three of these are at play in "Memento". The film is his best cinematic representation of this troika of characteristics, each of which is in constant tension with the other. Leonard grapples with them, and the film's precision and tone beautifully enhance Leonard's search for truth and meaning.


In the director's other works, such as his debut film "Following", isolation and anti-social characteristics form one man's search for connection as he randomly follows complete strangers for research on his novel. In Mr. Nolan's "Insomnia" (2002), the remake of the 1997 Norwegian film, Al Pacino is consumed by both a lack of sleep and a permanent daylight in Alaska, both deeply affecting his perception. In "Batman Begins" (2005), there's isolation, duality and the evolution of a man's single-minded quest to avenge the death of his parents. In "The Prestige" (2006), male rivals tangle in a game of one-upmanship and illusion. In "The Dark Knight" (2008), Gotham's lonely caped crusader was crime-fighter-in-crisis, overmatched by a public's expectations and perceptions of a hero, as well as wily villainy.


Mr. Nolan's forthcoming film "Inception" will likely prove just as intriguing as "Memento".


"Memento", the best work of Mr. Nolan's career, was released by Newmarket Films in 2001 and went on to gross about $40 million worldwide. In the intervening years, the film has gained huge admiration. For those who haven't seen it, "Memento" is a highly recommended mindbender.



Omar Moore's website is www.popcornreel.com. He's also on Twitter at @popcornreel.














In my college editing class, we were asked to take our favorite films and
edit them down to less than six minutes. This is what I came up with.





19 Comments

I've seen all kinds of films in my life, but I keep coming back to this one as my favorite of all time. Everything is just held so tightly together, and its basically a complex character study. Its hard to explain it to people so it doesn't sound like just a gimmick movie (and I'm sure its responsible for its share of terrible reverse knockoffs) but the time dynamic never fails to impress me.

Omar: Excellent point to compare Memento with "Shutter Island", it makes me wonder why I completely bought Pierce's dilemma and never DeCaprio's, or rather, why my subconscious did and didn’t respectively, when the first one was even more far-fetched I think.

I loved this movie! Can't wait to see the thing in chronological order, either.

In terms of the color of the movie, I seemed to notice a lot of green - a wall, draperies, a ceiling lamp. Not sure if that was "artful" or meaningful.

Thanks for the review. I need to see this - to-nyte!

Hi Omar,

Nice one. Have you seen Ganjini (Bollywood version of Memento)?

I frequently show MEMENTO in my classes exploring the history of religion, illustrating that religious history is often a generation-by-generation process of the same type of amnesia.

I also snicker when people call the movie MOMENTO.

I hope all is well.

Omer M


This film never ceases to amaze me, Matthew. Thanks for commenting!!

Watching the reverse (or chronological version) of the film on disc two of the special 2-DVD U.S. release (2002) is highly recommended if you haven't yet done so.

Hi Gerardo:

Yes indeed and thanks - I got much more mileage out of this film than Shutter Island. I felt that Scorsese's film worked harder and alienated some of its audience, while Nolan's Memento worked smart and engaged its viewers. Memento, despite its elements of rearrangement, is less disorderly a film than Shutter Island.

Thanks for the comment wxgddss! I think the color scheme is artful and intentional - a definite marker for the inner workings of the character played by Guy Pearce.

I loved the contrasting stories, one shot in black and white - the other in color. The pace of both stories is very different and I strongly suspect that this is also not by accident.

I'm glad you really liked the film!

Hi Omer --

Thanks for commenting!

I have not seen Ganjini but would love to see it. Memento is quite a film and ever since I first saw it in 2001 when it was released theatrically in the U.S. it has fascinated me to no end.

Memento--Momento, Potato--Po-ta-toe. Same difference, right? :-)

The David Bowie thing with Guy Pearce's character - I couldn't help noticing the coincidences (or non-coincidences). I'd love to talk to Christopher Nolan about them.

Without giving anything away for those who may not have seen Memento, do you think a sequel could be made for the film?

I think one could be made, but set maybe in San Francisco or in a city overseas (outside the U.S.)

What do you think? Do you think a sequel would work? Does anyone think that a follow-up film would "tarnish" the original? Thanks!

Please comment away!

I was disappointed by Shutter Island. David Cronenberg mastered the same intention with Spider, creating a truly remarkable tale of mental illness...8 years ago.

Memento has one of my all-time favourite movie endings. It's incredible how Nolan managed to wrap up The Answer in roughly the last minute of the movie (I'm referring to the scenes when Leonard is driving ('back') to the Tattoo Parlor). Throughout the minute, we're slowly figuring out how everything works.

And then he arrives and says, "So. Where was I?". The movie cuts straight to a black screen and then "Something in the Air" switches on.

That moment of finality was just perfect, in my mind.

I second that - any fan of Memento should se the hash made of it in Aamir Khan's Ghajini

Dear Roger, I love almost everything you write. But please, for my sanity, please, oh, please, stop retweeting Sarah Palin. She thrives on the exposure, especially in Twitter where retweets are currency. Sorry, this is clearly off-topic, but Palin is known for writing stuff on her body, so...well, there...

I‘m still not so enthusiastic about this movie as you and others do. Maybe due to big hoopla about it at that time, I think. I found it relatively simple even with ingenious story device. I didn't feel need to watch it twice because I perceived lots of thing immediately and got pretty much idea of what's going on or, should I say, what's spinning backward earlier than I expected. Watching DVD several years later did not change my opinion much. Maybe I should give it another try to see its greatness.


But the story is more than clever gimmick and following twists. Poor Leonard is practically spinning his wheel every 10 minutes and he will be forever locked in his maze by his alter egos as well as others. Sad thing is, while we gradually realize that fact in the end, he will probably never learn it. In case of the hero in "Shutter Island"(By the way, I like that movie), the situation can be tragically sad because he may have a choice in the end. In case of Leonard, it's hopelessly sad because he isn't capable of that from the beginning.


It seems pretty much dour, but "Memento" is quite entertaining with morbid sense of humor. There is action scene with hilarious side ("OK, so what am I doing?"). Screenplay has good dialogues and I especially found scenes at the bar very amusing. And the movie is thought-provoking story about memory, perception, and identity. Above all, it also works well as good mystery thriller without being too ponderous about its themes. In these days, the movie like "Memento" is valuable a lot.


Guy Pierce did wonderful job; he is basically playing at least 10 versions of his character and he somehow makes us to care about this incorrigibly discontinuous hero throughout running time. It's a little sad to see he hasn't got another meaty role yet since this movie, but I'm glad to see him appear briefly in movies you mentioned.


I watched "Ghajini" last year. Sadly, unintentional laugh is much shorter than running time(3hrs). It's just soap drama with short term memory loss, cartoonish actions(now I believe Jason Bourne more than ever), and, of course, song and dance numbers. The hero seems to have been doing lots of workout and we even see him running on treadmill in his personal gym(he's very rich). Wow, what will happen if his 10 minutes is over during doing that? I didn't see any notes attached on treadmill.

I recently re-watched Memento and was amazed yet again. The few words I wrote on the film pale in comparison to your article; thanks for taking the time to point out some of the more nuanced elements of Nolan's most remarkable achievement.

The blue tinge hasn't been something I've consciously been aware of, but in retrospect is readily apparent. Nolan seems smart and clever enough to make its use symbolic and much more than a gimmick.

I've often been surprised at those who find the film, especially its presentation, gimmicky and glossy. If enough attention is paid it becomes clear that much more is going on than the simple story of a strange amnesiac.

Thanks again for the article; watching the film for the first time in a few years has renewed my interest in Inception.

POSSIBLE SPOILER:

Regarding a Memento sequel: Would it be a spoiler to say that Joe Pantoliano dies at the "end?"

Omer M

What is the point of watching the film in chronological order? Do you rip open a magic box so you can see the mechanism of how it hides your quarter when you put it and open it to reveal its disappeared? Further more I do not find the comparison with Shutter Island apt at all, just a revelation of your distaste with a film you're not discussing. Further more the trick of this movie is to give its protagonist a disorder that will allow the plot turns to merely seem interesting and creative, as opposed to being interesting and creative. It's simple manipulation.

Excellent, insightful essay about a great movie.

One thing -- it's not "short-term memory loss". I don't know why that misnomer has become so wide-spread.

Leonard's short-term memory works fine; that's the memory of the past few seconds, under a minute anyway. In a normal brain, that memory is either lost or transferred to long-term memory; Leonard has lost the ability to do the latter. So "long-term memory loss" would make more sense, although "anterograde amnesia" is correct.

Let's just say that Joe Pantoliano dies in Leonard Shelby's mind.

Leave a comment

Edited by Roger Ebert

Click for RogerEbert.com

our far-flung correspondents

rogerffc.jpg


Our Far-Flung Correspondents are commentators from all over the world, who contribute their reviews and observations. The FFCs are fine writers from (alphabetically) Brazil, Canada, Egypt, India, Mexico, the Philippines, South Korea, Turkey and the U.S. They meet every year at Ebertfest. Comments are open. -- RE

Recent Comments

  • Omar Moore: Let's just say that Joe Pantoliano dies in Leonard Shelby's read more
  • Steven Doyle: Excellent, insightful essay about a great movie. One thing -- read more
  • John Keefer: What is the point of watching the film in chronological read more
  • Omer M. Mozaffar: POSSIBLE SPOILER: Regarding a Memento sequel: Would it be a read more
  • Tim Irwin: I recently re-watched Memento and was amazed yet again. The read more
  • Seongyong Cho: I‘m still not so enthusiastic about this movie as you read more
  • EbertFaninNC: Dear Roger, I love almost everything you write. But please, read more
  • Filmistan: I second that - any fan of Memento should se read more
  • Phil: Memento has one of my all-time favourite movie endings. It's read more
  • eduardo lopez: I was disappointed by Shutter Island. David Cronenberg mastered the read more