Jump to a:

LIVE BLOG: LeBron invites... (7/03/2008 15:31:59 PM) Big basketball weekend ahead... (6/19/2008 16:41:07 PM) Crandall Head is coming to Chicago (6/12/2008 16:12:46 PM) Lavonte Dority picks up an offer from Kansas (6/10/2008 18:18:40 PM)

King for a Day
Welcome to The Other Side »
« Contenders and Pretenders?

Over on my website at EDGYTIM.com, we have a simple rule among the many message board posters and contributors at this time of the year.

When it comes to the IHSA state football playoff system, feel free to complain all you want, that is until the games begin.

Once the games begin, regardless of your issues with our system, put your arguments and thoughts aside for the games, the coaches and the kids.

So as we get ever closer to the release of the IHSA State Football Playoff Pairings on Saturday, October 20th (a night that for myself has become a combination of Christmas, New Years Eve and my birthday all wrapped up into one glorious night) I feel a responsibility to at least get my ya-ya's out regarding what I feel is to a certain degree one messed up system.

So if I was King for a Day and had the authority to rule over everything that was the IHSA Football Playoff system?

Well, here we go then. All Hail King EDGY?

1. Seed each class of the state playoffs 1-32- Currently, we seem to flip flop between seeding each class either as 2 brackets of 16 teams or 4 8 team quads depending upon travel. Personally, the two 16 teams brackets I feel are a marked improvement from the original 4 8 team quads, yet this is still a flawed system on many levels.

Now, the IHSA over the past few years has stated many times that they have no real interest in ensuring that the best two teams make it to a state final. Huh? Yes, no need to back-track on that statement. The current IHSA playoff system wants to ensure that equal parts of the state have an equal chance to make it to the state finals regardless of the competition level. To the state association, location is king.

In my first act as King for the Day? Bye bye location and welcome to a true seeding per class. I know the naysayers will argue the cost of travel these days, yet how much of the educational experience are kids missing these days because they won't ever get to experience say a 2-3 hour bus ride to a different area of the state for a game? I say they are missing one of the best parts of the state playoff experience.

From a competition standpoint? No question we would have great match-ups regardless of location and yes, hopefully the best teams regardless of location would make the state finals. Let's stop trying to take the competition out of competitive sports. Look kids, in the state playoffs as well as in life. someone will lose and someone will win. It's life, and the sooner we teach that lesson and stop handing out trophies and pizza to everyone, the better in my book.

2. Under no circumstances shall any two conference foes face each other in the first round- Nothing gets me more upset with our current state playoff system than when two teams who face each other get to square off again in Week 10. It gets even worse when two conference teams who just played each other in Week 9 get to play each other in Week 10. It's silly and unfair in my book. If you seed 1-32 and those two teams face each other still in the bracket, then by all means move one team down and another up until you can avoid those types of match-ups.

3. Day and time of all playoff games shall be determined by the home team- End of story. Don't wanna play on a Friday night in the playoffs as the visiting team? Well, if the home team claims they want Friday night, then under my reign of terror the home team sets the day and time. The only allowable scenario is travel. If the visiting team needs to travel say more than 150 miles for a game, then let's revert back to the current system and let the administrators and coaches handle it. If they can't handle it, then the IHSA gets involved and sets the time and date.

I have plenty more, and I could write an entire blog on the 8 class football system we have now in Illinois, but maybe we'll say that subject for another day.

Hey, the King for a Day only has so much time to gets things done.

So what would you do if you were King or Queen for a Day?

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://blogs.suntimes.com/cgi-bin/mt-tb.cgi/4313

Comments

To start, I’d get rid of that multiplier and then agree with everything you said above.

And Tim, I'm looking forward to that promised blog on the 8 class system. Just ten days left before playoff pairings. Can you fit it in next week? How about a mid week special edition rant? It's cathartic for your readers.

Never really looked at it that closely but... If I understand the pairing system correctly> If the playoffs were held today, Lincoln Way Central (13) would host Andrew (20). The two play at Andrew this Friday. It's going to be a huge game for both teams and even more so given the pairing system.

Thanks for bringing this to light for us casual observers.

Joe

Oh....Go T-Bolts!

I too would rid of regional seedings. Then I'd increase the multiplier. Cant have 8A JCA and Providence playing 6A schools!! Thats about as fair as having Maine South playing St. Eds.

Edgy,
Great article as usual. But to satisfy downstate split the 8 class system in half. 5A - 8A seeded 1-32 in each class and play the championship at NIU or ISU ( alot closer than U of I ) and better attendance.

1A - 4A is a lot tougher since most of the schools are downstate. I would keep the 2 16 team brackets and continue the championship game at the U of I.

Post a comment


(I understand that the information I provide here will be published with my comment)









A product of the Sun-Times News Group  

© Copyright 2008 Digital Chicago, Inc.
Cell Phone Alerts Facebook App Contact Us Terms of Use Privacy Policy Advertise With Us