I thought life was good.
Airfare from Midway to Fort Lauderdale on Southwest - $60 each way.
Hotel on South Beach - $110 a night via Priceline.
Sun - ZERO.
Welcome to South Beach this past weekend. Lovely, let me tell you. While it was overcast the entire weekend, it was in the mid 70s - so I know...cry me a river. But I did catch a little high school soccer (Florida just started its state playoffs) and saw Dwayne Wade take on LeBron James last night.
Nevertheless, I've received dozens of emails over the past week regarding the recent blogs. It's interesting to see what major Division I college coaches think. And now, lucky you, you'll get to see what I think.
Honestly, my main thought is to each their own. I grew up playing baseball, and I would've died to play baseball year round and travel half as much as some younger athletes do today. My sister, who played softball at Sandburg and at UIC, has already traveled to more places than I may in my entire life.
Are kids playing too much? To each their own. Each person is different. But the physical activity, the social relationships and experiences they gain can't be overlooked. What kid wouldn't want to travel to the Disney Soccer Showcase over the holidays, get out of the cold and hangout with their friends?
As for the whole high school/club debate, it sort of cracks me up now. I have club coaches who say I'm pro high school, and high school coaches who say I'm pro club. Blah, blah, blah, ego, ego, ego.
Guess what? I'm pro kid, and that's what some of the idoits involved in this sport tend to forget.
If a kid wants to play high school - great. I believe, and always will, that there are many benefits to playing high school - even for the best soccer player around. Look at the number of professional players that have played high school from the area. I love the Brad Guzan reference, because he played for a major club (Chicago Magic), played for a small high school (Class A Providence), played for a so-so college soccer program (South Carolina), plays in the MLS, the U.S. Men's National Team and will most likely be in Europe someday...maybe this season.
And that's just one of the thousands of examples on the boys and girls side.
Soccer experts from all over can say a kid needs to this or that, but again - look at every other sport. Nine out of 10 times, the best athletes play high school. Just because you play high school doesn't always mean you aren't getting the best coaching or experience. Tony Kees (Conant), Markus Roy (York) and Alex Hernandez (Lyons) all coached high school soccer, and now they are coaching for the Fire Academy. Mike Matkovich (Chicago Magic) and Rory Dames (Eclipse) played and coached high school.
I think it's safe to say all five of these guys turned out all right.
But with all of that said, there are more opportunities out there these days for kids. If a high school player wants to play club, let them. I think it's horrible when a high school coach pressures a high school student to play soccer. It goes on all the time and it's sad. I've listened to kids tell me stories of where a coach, who teaches in the school, stops talking to them. To be honest, if that happens this year - every coach that does that should be fired.
Club has made the sport better and will continue to improve it.
The problem here is the IHSA-YSO. I have finally realized it needs to allow kids to do both during the same season. Other states do it, and it works fine. Allow the kids to travel to major recruiting tournaments during the season. Players today are playing for college scholarships and hopefully the love of the game.
As I pointed out last week, there were more college coaches at this year's Disney Soccer Showcase than I have seen at every high school soccer game I have covered over the past 12 years combined.
High school is second class in the recruiting scene and always will be. As Lake Zurich girls soccer coach Pete Ternes said to me last week - the IHSA-YSO doesn't care about having the best soccer players play high school or getting the best teams to the state finals.
The average team and average player's money is as good as the best team and best player's money. People nail club, saying it's all money. At the end of the day, some need to look at the IHSA-YSO and ask the same question.
If people are willing to pay, nothing is going to change. And until that changes, as I said - to each their own.
- Joe Trost