Sky Blue posted 1-0 victories over the Red Stars on April 11 in Piscataway, N.J., and April 25 at Toyota Park.
Sky Blue is 5-0-1 record against the Red Stars during the teams' first two seasons.
"As far as the past stuff, something's got to give at some point, right?" Red Stars coach Omid Namazi said in a release. "We've just got to continue to play the way we've been possessing the ball, and making sure that we create enough chances and give ourselves a chance to stick one in the back of the net and come up with the 'W.'"