Chicago Sun-Times
Stray Casts will intelligently report and observe, hopefully with a touch of wit, on daily occurrences, reports and releases related to Chicago-area outdoors from bucks to bass to birds to bugs

Illinois deer hunting: Bizarre double earn-a-buck proposed

| 3 Comments | No TrackBacks

buck2011tight.jpg State Sen. John O. Jones (R-Mt. Vernon) has proposed

a double earn-a-buck bill for Illinois in SB3316.

Click here for more on the proposal by Jones, a Republican leader in the Senate.

I'm not opposed to earn-a-buck as a management tool, and there are areas in Illinois where I think this unpopular method might be needed.

But other than that, this bill doesn't make much sense on many levels.

My suspicious side made me wonder if the IDNR was floating a trail balloon, but that was shot down completely by forest wildlife program manager Paul Shelton.

He took time out from CWD culling yesterday for this response:

No, it didn't come from us. And it's not just "earn a buck" - it's "double earn a buck", since hunters would be required to harvest 2 antlerless deer prior to harvesting a buck.

Implementing programs like that can be very effective for population reduction in seriously overpopulated areas, although they tend to be so unpopular with hunters that in many cases they are viewed as a last resort. In any event, they are designed for a single purpose - to drastically reduce populations. And they will continue to do so as long as they are in place. When populations reach goal, the regulations must be removed, else populations continue to decline to even lower levels. There is no mechanism to allow this in the proposed bill, so it would seem that the intent of the bill is to keep driving the deer population ever lower... In counties with limited habitat and already low deer population levels, the dramatic effects of this approach will be seen quickly.

I was surprised to see such legislation, because after the creation of the Deer Population Task Force in 2008 by the Illinois General Assembly (House Joint Resolution 65), deer goals were recommended and adopted, and on a statewide basis we have pretty much reached goal (although some individual counties remain above or below goal). Our current approach of using county permit quotas (both either-sex and antlerless-only) for gun seasons, and the availability of additional seasons to supplement harvest where necessary, has served us well. This approach allows us to increase harvest or decrease harvest as necessary in all the state's individual units. This gives us much more flexibility and versatility in addressing the needs of a myriad of different situations found throughout the state's different counties.

No TrackBacks

TrackBack URL:


I think he missed the idea of "earn a 2nd buck tag" ie... a hunter would have to harvest a doe before being able to harvest a 2nd buck, but to harvest 2 does before evening taking your 1st buck would never fly.

Too many cheaters in this state already, hunters using their kids, wives, brother's tags. So while some guys currently take 2 bucks a year, I'm sure plenty take more than 2 and use others tags.

Not sure if you guys are aware of this, but Wisconsin recently abolished Earn-a-Buck via state legislature as a management tool.
It was highly unpopular with hunters, but did work.
We have too many deer up here in many areas, and the October antlerless-only season also got cut. Most hunters up here want more deer than the areas can hold for better hunting, but we also have baiting up here, and that pushes the deer to move at night, and then the hunters complain they don't see anything when hunting!

I hope you guys learn from our mistakes.
We still have a December antlerless gun season, but it has minimal effect because it's typically pretty cold and nasty then.

Leave a comment

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Dale Bowman published on February 14, 2012 5:59 PM.

Radio waves: Kath, alligator snappers & bats on "Outside" was the previous entry in this blog.

Stray Cast: Fukudome, Sox, temperate bass, Heidecke is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.