Chicago Sun-Times
Stray Casts will intelligently report and observe, hopefully with a touch of wit, on daily occurrences, reports and releases related to Chicago-area outdoors from bucks to bass to birds to bugs

Fish of the Week: Smallmouth on the fly

| 6 Comments | No TrackBacks

On an August evening, Chuck Atkins caught one of the biggest smallmouth bass from Lake Michigan.


Until somebody proves otherwise, I credit him with the greatest smallmouth caught and released by a fly fisherman on the Illinois lakefront in the history of Chicago fishing.

The Portage Park man also earns Fish of the Week honors for a smallmouth estimated around 23 inches and 6-plus pounds.

``Was she the real monster I have been searching for?,'' he said. ``Nope, but I'm gettin' closer! . . . This one was a real challenge to land because the waves were really crashing against the rocks [that] night!''

Atkins, 50, an artist and retail manager for Father Time Antiques on Belmont, came late in life to fishing.

``I am arrogant fly fisherman, I think it is a bigger deal to catch a fish on fly rod than conventional rod,'' he said.

His real love is chasing steelhead on the tributaries around southern Lake Michigan. But he also learned to catch carp with flies on Lake Michigan flats.

``People should have more respect for carp,'' he said. ``When they are in Lake Michigan, they are a whole different animal.''

He found smallmouth mixed with the carp, and learned to target them.

Crayfish are a favored forage of smallmouth. So his favorite flies are a hexagenia nymph imitation, a venerable trout fly that also imitates a crayfish, or Dave Whitlock's famous Near Nuff Crayfish.

Good enough patterns to force considering fishing protocol.

``I can't kill a fish like that,'' he said. ``If I was really intent on chasing the state record, I would carry a scale. . . . I used to carry a Boga-Grip [scales], but I think those are really bad for fish.''

So he releases his fish and estimates weight from length/girth formulas.

``Did I release a state record?'' he asked. ``Probably not but she was close and she's out there growing bigger, so, I'm happy! . . . I think there are smallmouth [out there] over 7 pounds.''


BTW, Mark Samp caught the 6-pound, 7-ounce Illinois smallmouth record from a Fulton County strip pit on March 26, 1985.

FOTW usually tops the Midwest Fishing Report on the outdours page of the Sun-Times each Wednesday. An extended online version appears here, usually by midnight Tuesday.

E-mail FOTW nominations to

No TrackBacks

TrackBack URL:


Awesome fish!!! Good job buddy!

Awsome fish on a fly. Congrats

How do you manage to get a 23" fish fully in frame with room to spare on an arm's-length photo? Chunky fish indeed but I'm not buying twenty-three inches.

It's nice to read about another beutiful 6+# Smallie caught and released in 2010! Great job and nice fish. It's just a matter of time before a new state record will be announced. Put your time in on the big lake and you may be rewarded!


I know exactly where that daisy is painted on the rocks, and I'm NOT Telling ;)
Nice Fish man!

take a pic of the rod next to a tape measure to silence the non-believers..from the end of the 4" Diameter reel, up the shaft.
Looks pretty darn close to 23" inches to me!
Fantastic fish!

Leave a comment

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Dale Bowman published on September 14, 2010 10:14 PM.

IHSA bass fishing: Finals extended at Carlyle was the previous entry in this blog.

Stray Cast: Muskies & Cubs is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.