Chicago Sun-Times
Stray Casts will intelligently report and observe, hopefully with a touch of wit, on daily occurrences, reports and releases related to Chicago-area outdoors from bucks to bass to birds to bugs

IDNR dismisses bowfishing bass notion

| 1 Comment | No TrackBacks

Below is the official word on why the IDNR will not have bowfishing for bass. What's left unanswered, at least to my satisfaction, is why that distinction and protection is not made for other native species when requested.

IDNR communications manager Stacey Solano sent this:

The IDNR believes that bowfishing for sportfish should not be allowed. We encourage catch and release in most instances to protect the resource. This management technique, although appropriate in some instances, could not be sustained with other demands on the fishery.

No, that sounds like a finely crafted PR response, but in a follow-up IDNR director Marc Miller sent this:

Dale, I can assure that virtually no response goes out without a director's approval. There may be some that are handled by Solano and [Chris] McCloud, but in this case I am the one who wrote the response as we circulated your question.

That's a hands-on approach from a natural resources professional.

Let's us know if you need anything else.

-Marc

That's the word from the top, and I am glad we live in a time when word comes from a pro at the top of the IDNR.

Yet, I very adamantly contend that a natural resources professional should also realize that the native vs non-native species distinction would be the most science-based broad means of dividing species for such pursuits as bowfishing, gigging, snagging, etc.

No TrackBacks

TrackBack URL: http://blogs.suntimes.com/cgi-bin/mt-tb.cgi/25272

1 Comment

Again Dale, no effort has been underway to legalize bowfishing for Bass as you are trying to say. You took a question I posed to you to try and make a headline. Anyway,that was all gone over in your last blog comment.

BUT, you and I have our answers from the DNR now dont we.

"The IDNR believes that bowfishing for sportfish should not be allowed. We encourage catch and release in most instances to protect the resource. This management technique, although appropriate in some instances, could not be sustained with other demands on the fishery."

Again, read....

"This management technique, although appropriate in some instances, could not be sustained with other demands on the fishery."

Its about the fishery Dale. NOT the fish! There just arent enough bass, walleyes musky ect.... to take with bow AND rod and reel.
Are we going to run out of gar? Buffalo? Drum?

No way, and the DNR knows this. And THAT is the reason we can bowfish for certain fish and not bowfish others. Not because of the species, not because its called a "game fish". But by how sustainable the resource is. Bowfishing, Line fishing, bow hunting and gun hunting are all just management techniques as the DNR states.
All questions answered Dale!

Leave a comment

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Dale Bowman published on August 26, 2009 11:18 AM.

Bowfishing bass OK: BAI prez was the previous entry in this blog.

Small world: Illinois to Michigan, and beyond is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.