Chicago Sun-Times

Video: Brendan Smith suspended eight total games for hit on Ben Smith

| 5 Comments | No TrackBacks

NHL disciplinarian Brendan Shanahan remained tough in his rulings this preseason and suspended Detroit Red Wings defenseman Brendan Smith the rest of the preseason and five regular-season games for his shoulder-to-head hit on Blackhawks forward Ben Smith.

Ben Smith is day-to-day with a concussion. Brendan Smith, who will likely start the year in the American Hockey League, also will forfeit $23,648.65 in salary, which goes to the Players' Emergency Assistance Fund. The Red Wings have three preseason games remaining.

"You look at this year, the suspensions have been lengthier than they have been in the past, and I think the players are going to adapt," coach Joel Quenneville said Friday at the United Center. "It's been kind of in line with the way things have been going. In the past, it wouldn't have been as severe. But I think this is a new era we're looking at."

Quenneville said Ben Smith is "doing the same" as he was Thursday. Smith was at the United Center as the Hawks practiced, offering the media a smile and wave as he left.

"You knew it was going to be up there, I think we thought 10-plus," Patrick Kane said. "They're pretty serious about what they're issuing these days. It seems like Benny is doing better. Hopefully, he won't even be out that long.

"That's one thing you don't want to see is the guy that gets hit is out longer than the guy that gets suspended. It seems like that's been the case with a lot of these hits the past couple times with guys with concussions. I know Smith the guy that hit him. He's a young kid. He's not a repeat offender, but it's still pretty hefty for a first [suspension]. Hopefully, Benny will be better."

The hit occurred at 5:26 of the third period in their exhibition game Wednesday at the United Center. Smith received a pass from Dave Bolland and skated toward the goal with Brendan Smith as the last line of defense. Brendan Smith lowered his shoulder striking Ben Smith in the head as he passed. Ben Smith lay face down on the ice for several moments and needed help to the locker room. Brendan Smith was assessed a match penalty.

Detroit coach Mike Babcock continued to argue Friday that some responsibility falls on the puck carrier, in this case Ben Smith, for putting himself in that position. Ben Smith appeared to make a slight move immediately before the hit.

"I thought it was a little extreme to tell you the truth," Babcock told reporters in Detroit. "I still believe when you're a left handed guy, chasing the guy and you put your stick down on the puck, so stick-on-stick, body-on-body, and the guy pulls back he's got some responsibility in this area as well.

"In saying that, we're not condoning anyone getting hit in the head with someone's shoulder or any of that. It's important, they're a work in progress at the league too trying to figure this all out and how to protect the players. He's going to learn from this and move on."

Shanahan took into consideration whether Ben Smith put himself in a vulnerable position immediately before or at the time of the hit. But he ruled (as seen in the above video) that Ben Smith "slightly changes his path. The positioning of his head does not significantly change. So the onus remains on Detroit's Brendan Smith to deliver a full-body check. Instead, Brendan Smith misses and recklessly targets his opponents' head. This is a violation of the illegal check to the head rule, which states 'a hit resulting in contact with an opponents' head, where the head is targeted and the principal point of contact, is not permitted.' "

Brendan Smith was the eighth player suspended this preseason by Shanahan for illegal hits. The longest his ex-Hawk James Wisniewski's eight regular-season game suspension. Whether he starts in the AHL or not, Brendan Smith will serve his five-game suspension for the regular season whenever he's with the Red Wings.

"I was sitting on the bench after the hit and was telling some of the guys it's scary because it seems like Benny ... just gets touched in the chin and the next thing you know he's out before he even hits the ice," Kane said. "It's scary. The onus is definitely on the puck carrier too where you come in and have to be aware of that. But I don't think Benny could really do anything in that situation."

Brendan Smith reached out and spoke to Ben Smith.

"I just apologized and said 'In no intentions did I try to do that,' " Brendan Smith told reporters in Detroit. "I was just trying to out-play that man, and try to make sure that he didn't get to the net, and not let him score. Obviously, some things can go wrong, and that was the worst possible thing that could happen.

"I'm going to have to learn from this, for sure. The game moves very quickly. I'm going to have to adjust to it, and make sure that I'm in the right place at the right time, so that will never happen."

No TrackBacks

TrackBack URL:


This is an impressively evenhanded article.

I think shanahan is doing a great job, and as Brendan smith said he's going to have to learn from it, and if the boot had been on the other foot and a hawk had done this I would say the same thing, car bomb is gonna really have to watch himself this season, because shanahan ain't messing around, and his rep proceeds itself

I too am impressed with the evenhandedness of this article. Thank you for this class act in reporting.

Babcock is always making excuses for goonish behavior. He has the premier head-hunter in the league, a cheap shot artist who never drops the gloves and always tries to hit guys when they are not looking, Kronwall. Bertuzzi should have been banned by the league years ago for what he did...ending a players career. Why is this goon allowed to contiue playing???

2 Smiths, 2 Brendans, good thing there is a video. Kane is right, a touch to the chin and a guy is out---thats why a right cross in boxing is so effective when it lands---its the chin and sudden neck snapping movement that comes from it, that makes the brain get quickly scrambled for a seemingly not so powerful impact.

I'm glad Brendan (Shanahan) is in charge of all of this now---a former player, from the modern era, using technology that is shared with all to see and understand quickly what his decision is about and future similiar hits will result in same and even more severe punishment. If the NHL wants more head hits, they should just teach all to lead with their helment like former HIgh School football coaches once taught, and be prepared to pay lots of medical payouts for CTE injuries during a players retirement.

Good decision all around---including the process used to determine, and share the findings for all (players and fans) to understand.

Good Luck Mr Smith (Ben)

Leave a comment


About the blogger

Adam L. Jahns is a native Chicagoan hailing from the Far Northwest Side. Jahns has been with the Sun-Times since 2005, covering the Hawks since 2009. He's also helped cover the Bears, Cubs, Sox and high schools.


About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Adam L. Jahns published on September 30, 2011 12:04 PM.

Injury report: Ben Smith, Dave Bolland are day-to-day; Viktor Stalberg out 3 weeks; Patrick Sharp may return was the previous entry in this blog.

Patrick Sharp returns to Blackhawks practice is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.