Chicago Sun-Times

Brian Urlacher injury might require 'D-Rose' approach

| 1 Comment | No TrackBacks

The Brian Urlacher situation remains extremely fluid at Bears training camp. Urlacher and the Bears either don't know what's wrong with his left knee or don't want to say.

Either way, it's a problem, as Lovie Smith's dismissive responses earlier in the week (''Brian is going to be our Mike linebacker this season'') have given way to virtual silence (''Knee is sore. He's been out for personal reasons. That's all we're going to talk on the subject,'' Smith said Saturday).

No longer are we hearing that there's nothing to worry about. Not that anybody was heeding Smith's contention that we were making too much of Urlacher's absence. Last Sunday, Nick Roach said, ''Brian will be fine. He's the last guy you have to worry about being ready to play.'' Two days later he told Bears sideline reporter Zach Zaidman, ''Like everybody else, I'm hoping and praying that he's healthy enough to come back.'' That seemed like an early indication there was something to worry about.

There are still four weeks before the Bears open the regular season against the Indianapolis Colts at Soldier Field on Sept. 9. But the issue with Urlacher isn't whether he'll be ready for that game. He might be. The issue is how he'll hold up once the season begins. If Urlacher's knee is sore enough for him to miss two weeks after three padded practices, how is it going to feel after playing two regular-season games in a five-day span to start the regular season (the Colts on Sept. 9, the Packers on Sept. 13)? Or the 14 games in 15 weeks after that?

Far be it from the Bears to think outside the box, but they might want to consider taking a "Derrick Rose approach" to Urlacher's injury and not let the nine-time Pro Bowl middle linebacker return until Oct. 22 against the Lions.

The schedule appears to allow for it. In the first five weeks of the season (Colts-Packers-Rams-Cowboys-Jaguars), the Bears play three teams that ranked in the bottom three of the NFL in offense last year -- the Colts (30th), Rams (31st) and Jaguars (32nd). Then they have a bye before playing the Lions at home on Monday Night Football. That would give Urlacher 10 more weeks to heal his left knee.

If that's too radical, the Bears could try a compromise strategy and play Urlacher against the Packers on Sept. 13 and the Cowboys on Oct. 1 -- both prime-time games, for whatever that's worth -- and rest him against the others.

That would allow the Bears to keep Urlacher in game shape without the usual wear-and-tear, develop an Urlacher replacement and -- this is the best part -- still win games. Unless the Colts, Rams and Jaguars make quantum leaps on offense this season, the Bears should not need Urlacher to beat any of them.

Is that possible? Would it work? Who knows? But the way the Urlacher saga is transpiring, it doesn't sound like the Bears have any better ideas.

No TrackBacks

TrackBack URL:

1 Comment

You know one of Lovie's rules is, if you don't practice you don't play. The idea behind it being if your not healthy enough to practice, your not healthy enough to play. Brian has clearly not been healthy enough to practice, but the Bears are assuming by not practicing he will be healthy enough to play. But playing nfl games does not make you healthy, it beats you up.

If your knee is so sore you can't practice after two weeks something is really wrong. If it's about preserving the veteran starters why is everyone else practicing? Why is Peppers out there, or Briggs or Tillman? If he is not running how is he keeping his endurance up. Endurance is the first thing that goes when you don't workout. I know he rested that knee most of the off-season so how is he even close to being in game shape?

I think it is easy to assume he was seeing doctors on those personal days and trying to figure out what could be done for his knee. My guess is he needs surgery but the doctors gave him the option of letting it rest and seeing how it feels.

Either way he never should have been on the field when he got hurt. That was just Lovie's pathetic ego, gosh we are 1 and 0 in 2012. That messed up Lovie math he always does. The game meant nothing, it was all ego.

Leave a comment

Twitter updates


About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Mark Potash published on August 12, 2012 8:45 AM.

Brian Urlacher returns to team but does not practice Saturday was the previous entry in this blog.

Brian Urlacher: 'I'll be ready' for Bears' opener is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.