If Marty loses again, it's a record

| | Comments (1) | TrackBacks (0)


LOS ANGELES — Among the five Academy Award directing nominees, one name seems to be on everyone’s lips: Martin Scorsese. Nominated five times previously for best director since the 1980 masterpiece ‘‘Raging Bull,’’ Scorsese has gone home a loser each year. With Scorsese’s sixth directing nomination, this one for his return to the vivid and violent crime genre on ‘‘The Departed,’’ seemingly everyone in Hollywood figures he finally will have his Oscar come Sunday.

Not that he’s up against a bunch of slouches. His formidable competition includes Clint Eastwood, who beat him for the directing Oscar two years ago and is nominated this time for the World War II saga ‘‘Letters From Iwo Jima.’’

Also nominated are two Brits, Stephen Frears for the insightful palace drama ‘‘The Queen’’ and Paul Greengrass for the Sept. 11 chronicle ‘‘United 93,’’ and Mexican director Alejandro Gonzalez Inarritu for the sprawling ensemble tale ‘‘Babel.’’

Scorsese has made no secret over the years that he’d like to have that trophy. Contemporaries of his stature, such as Steven Spielberg and Francis Ford Coppola, have long since won theirs.

The chatty Scorsese has been modest and terse through awards season about his Oscar history and his prospects this time.

Last fall, as ‘‘The Departed’’ arrived in theaters, he said of his Oscar shutout: ‘‘I guess it’s all right. I’m disappointed, of course. But you don’t make pictures to win Oscars.’’

After winning the Directors Guild of America’s top filmmaking honor — which almost always is a precursor to an Oscar triumph — Scorsese was coy when asked if this was his year to win an Oscar.

‘‘I don’t know,’’ Scorsese said. ‘‘It’s good to have a nomination, especially for this picture.’’

Along with ‘‘Raging Bull,’’ Scorsese previously was nominated as best director for ‘‘The Last Temptation of Christ,’’ ‘‘Goodfellas,’’ ‘‘Gangs of New York’’ and ‘‘The Aviator.’’ Scorsese also had two screenplay nominations for co-writing ‘‘Goodfellas’’ and ‘‘The Age of Innocence,’’ losing both times.

A sixth loss would put Scorsese in the record books as the director with the most nominations without winning.

If Scorsese wins, it arguably will be for a lesser film compared to his best work. Still, despite the repetitive violence that concludes ‘‘The Departed,’’ the story of rival mob and police moles is magnificently directed, resurrecting much of the sardonic humor, wiseguy interplay and savage grandeur of Scorsese’s vintage films.

Many thought Scorsese should have won for ‘‘Raging Bull,’’ but the directing prize that year went to Robert Redford for ‘‘Ordinary People,’’ which also beat Scorsese’s film for best picture.

‘‘I voted for him back in the ‘Raging Bull’ days as an academy member,’’ Eastwood said. ‘‘Everybody thought that would be his moment. It still is one of his defining films.’’

Two years ago, awards watchers branded the directing category a showdown between Eastwood for ‘‘Million Dollar Baby’’ and Scorsese for ‘‘The Aviator.’’ A previous best-director winner for ‘‘Unforgiven,’’ Eastwood beat out Scorsese, and ‘‘Million Dollar Baby’’ also took best picture over ‘‘The Aviator.’’

While sentiment is firmly with Scorsese this time, some Oscar analysts have revived the notion of a two-man race, saying Eastwood could be a spoiler.

‘‘I really don’t like that, and I don’t think Marty does — and don’t think any of the other nominees do, because it’s not fair to the other nominees who have done good work — to have people pitting the two senior guys. Whoever delivers the goods, they’d like to win on delivering the goods,’’ Eastwood said. ‘‘When you make a sporting event out of it, it really shouldn’t be like that.’’

Eastwood’s nomination was a bit surprising considering he was overlooked by the Directors Guild, whose contenders usually line up closely to the Oscars’. The guild recipient has gone on to earn the directing Oscar 53 of 59 times, solidifying Scorsese’s chances.

Yet in Eastwood’s case, academy voters may have been honoring him for a remarkable dual achievement, directing ‘‘Letters From Iwo Jima’’ and the companion film ‘‘Flags of Our Fathers’’ in a single year.


0 TrackBacks

Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: If Marty loses again, it's a record.

TrackBack URL for this entry: http://blogs.suntimes.com/cgi-bin/mt-tb.cgi/2472


Martin Scorsese deserves one this year for, "the Departed", he has been passed up so many times, it's unbelievable that he hasn't
won already!! Hopefully this time will be THE TIME HE WINS!!!

Leave a comment

Type the characters you see in the picture above.

Awards calendar

Your complete calendar of upcoming entertainment awards shows and other related events! To mark your calendar, click here.

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Thomas Conner published on February 22, 2007 11:58 AM.

Many Oscar films already on disc was the previous entry in this blog.

Everyone loves Ennio Morricone is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.